• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • Entertainment
  • Music
Why did Britney Spears stop singing live so early on?
xmel05
08-06-2012
Yes! I know that she didnt always sing live back in the day but she used to sing parts of Baby one more time live when she first started out and she sounded quite good considering she used to dance.

I dont get why she completely stopped?

She very rarely sings anything live these days.
mkirilenkofan
08-06-2012
Really? What a pointless thread.

She is the USA equivalent to Cheryl Cole. Not a lot of talent.
AdzPower
08-06-2012
Im not sure exactly, only she knows for sure, but I already think you've answered your own question, choreography, the dancing she used to do wasnt a cheesy Steps routine, it was full on hip/hop style dancing, Britney cares more about putting on a show for her fans rather than punishing them by singing live, not that she cant, its just that she cant whilst doing such heavy choreo, if she did both she would sound terrible and out of breath, she puts showmanship before singing. Although lately she has been singing a lot more live at her shows because she does less dancing, so its good she's switching it up a bit.
MrIncredible
08-06-2012
Because she has the vocal ability of a cream bun.
Pumpkin Soup
08-06-2012
Choreography excuses her until 2004. That's all I'll say.
GOGO2
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by mkirilenkofan:
“Really? What a pointless thread.

She is the USA equivalent to Cheryl Cole. Not a lot of talent.”

How very dare you!!

Britney has charm, personality, star quality and a back catologue of genuinely great pop songs.

Cheyl Cole has a pretty face and Simon Cowel, she's not fit to lick Britney's boots.
spm2012
08-06-2012
Britney miming has never really been an issue to me as I think her studio voice is so recognisable that its all she really needs during her shows.
GOGO2
08-06-2012
Quote:
“Why did Britney Spears stop singing live so early on?”

Because she's got all the money in the world and two little boys, perhaps.
MrIncredible
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by GOGO2:
“How very dare you!!

Britney has charm, personality, star quality and a back catologue of genuinely great pop songs.

Cheyl Cole has a pretty face and Simon Cowel, she's not fit to lick Britney's boots. ”

While Britney has a slightly haggard face and Simon Cowell.
GOGO2
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by MrIncredible:
“While Britney has a slightly haggard face and Simon Cowell.”

Plus charm, personality, sex appeal and decent pop songs...

and theres nothing wrong with her face, your just being bitchy. And as if she needs Simon Cowel!!
barneyboy
08-06-2012
Britney has the most amazing personality. For the first album and more simple dance routines she sang live. Her dancing improved and became more intricate, she lipped. It was a downward spiral, she hurt her knee got mentally unwell and didnt go back to the start.
GOGO2
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by barneyboy:
“Britney has the most amazing personality. For the first album and more simple dance routines she sang live. Her dancing improved and became more intricate, she lipped. It was a downward spiral, she hurt her knee got mentally unwell and didnt go back to the start.”

I don't think she should either. I hope she's enjoying simply being a filthy rich mum of two beautiful boys.
Pumpkin Soup
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by GOGO2:
“I don't think she should either. I hope she's enjoying simply being a filthy rich mum of two beautiful boys.”

I agree. I think she's loving the X Factor because she's not being forced into promo talking about loving albums. She seems genuinely excited about being able to focus on something other than her own project.

It's nice to see her happy
madiain28
08-06-2012
Not really sure why people get soo upset about this. So she has sold millions of records made millions of pounds filled the headlines for years. Lip synced throughout her career. Now suddenly the music Police are up in arms. So she hasn't got the best voice join the Q of the majority of pop artists. She's not singing opera, classical or any other type of music that requires the perfect voice. It's pop music it's a product packaged to choreographed dance routines. Don't like it don't buy it don't go to her shows. Personally I wouldn't thank you for a ticket but lots if kids over the past 10 or so years grew up with her and enjoy the whole bubblegum pop era of Britney.
I just don't understand why we suddenly have the music Police shredding half a dozen artists at the moment re lip syncing. All artists who have heave dance routines do it. This includes Madonna, Gaga, and most probably the majority of pop concerts and has been for years it's not just suddenly happened. HD recording equipment and crystal clear tv equipment shows it more obviously compared to the hazy old VHS recordings or tv broadcasts.
ScottishWoody
08-06-2012
I was at her last tour, I'm not gonna say it was 100% live, but about half of it was! Search for her performing Dont Let Me Be The Last To Know, outstanding live vocals.
LynxSoldier
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by ScottishWoody:
“I was at her last tour, I'm not gonna say it was 100% live, but about half of it was! Search for her performing Dont Let Me Be The Last To Know, outstanding live vocals.”

Lol mte.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YpUbKFN7k80

Haha at her being the USA Cheryl ...

Not to mention:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TX1hAEVP2mY

And to be fair to Cheryl, she can technically sing. Good vibrato, good riff control. Where she lacks is consistency and range, the former being very easily fixed with practice (look at Kylie and Madonna, neither could sing particularly well early on).
MrMeatAndPotato
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by GOGO2:
“Plus charm, personality, sex appeal and decent pop songs...

and theres nothing wrong with her face, your just being bitchy. And as if she needs Simon Cowel!! ”

She didn't solely write those "decent pop songs".
caren197
08-06-2012
I'll never understand why people find it so strange or surprising she doesn't choose to sing live. Back in the the 90s no one sang 100% live and no one ever had a problem with it.

Personally i prefer performance anf would prefer listening to someone mime and than sing awfully bad and try to dance.
I really enjoyed cheryls performance on the voice for example, she performed brilliantly, so what if she didn't sing live, she was found on a singing reality show, its not entirely fair to say she just cannot sing when she made it through how many thousands on that show and has been probably the second lead in GA?? She may not be a strong singer but she is one he'll of a performer.

Much like Britney, she'll never sing better than christina but her concerts were 100% more enjoyable than christinas (back in the day) because she was such a great performer. I just dont think I'll ever understand this whole 'shoot them they never sang live' thing. Just doesn't make any sense to me!!
GOGO2
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by MrMeatAndPotato:
“She didn't solely write those "decent pop songs".”

And?

They are her songs, the same as Elvis's songs are his. They don't need to have written them.
SCDchick
08-06-2012
Because she is shite.....
toanythingtaboo
08-06-2012
Originally Posted by GOGO2:
“Because she's got all the money in the world and two little boys, perhaps.”

Er...
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map