Originally Posted by si29uk:
“For all the quality of Sophie Okonedo's acting, I just didn't feel she convinced as a teenage bride.
I know Shakespeare plays fast and loose with the historical timelines - but Margaret is very young at this point in the narrative.
They have a younger actor playing Cecily, Duchess of York who later transforms into Judi Dench for the final episode (Richard III) - so why not go down a similar route for Margaret?
I think audiences can buy into having different actors playing the same character at different points through their lives.
Okonedo will be amazing at the later Margaret - I just felt she is too old to play someone aged between 15 and early 20s (as she is supposed to be in the first part)
She is a really talented actor - and may get away with the role on stage, but in close up, her face just shows too much maturity.”
Agree, the length of time where Margaret is young and (relatively) innocent just didn't work for Sophie. I know she commented that they filmed all the different parts of this epic simultaneously, so she could be an 'old hag' one scene, and then switching to 'intended bride' another. For me, this was the weak link - despite her brilliance in the later scenes. Sophie is 47 - basically far too old to play Margaret as a teenager. I get why they chose Sophie, because she played the whole 'she-wolf' thing brilliantly (and for me her race was a total non-issue), but the other scenes jarred, especially when Tom Sturridge is so young looking, and played the teenage king perfectly. I suppose you can handwave it all away that Margaret was a 'mother/father substitute' for the king, and allow for her looking older, when she certainly acted more maturely.
BTW, it always jars for me when Romeo and Juliet are played by obviously 20- or 30-somethings, so it's not just this! Also, I've seen Richard III previously, but not the Henry VI plays, so it's interesting to see what a Tudor-sponsored hatchet job Shakespeare did on all of the Plantagenets, not just the Hunchback Superbad! It's not subtle, is it?!! I am looking forward to next week's installment - Benedict was electrifying when delivering his monologues, so there'll be lots more of that!