Similar to that 'Girls Aloud' one, and this includes their upcoming one 'More Than This which is out in a week's time (though they don't seem to have time to promote it so possibly won't do well).

I think What Makes You Beautiful remains the best, not only because it's the most popular, but most appealing, catchy etc.

They've only done like 3 haven't they?!

Gotta Be You

I find their fans REALLY scary btw was checking out a Little Mix video the other day and some One Direction fangirls were wanting Perrie Edwards dead because they felt she was using Zayn Malik.

It was very disturbing to read as they were deadly serious.

This is the best one:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t7CHfqg0wd8

Lol

Dont have a favourite 1D song and not a 1D fan but WMUB is the catchiest and most successful? song they have done so far. So I would say that makes it their best.

Not a fan but actually like their new song.

Hmm shouldn't we wait until the second album for this kind of thread...
But out of the three i'll go with WMYB. Gotta Be You is the weakest single and one of the weakest on the entire album for me.

I prefer the B-side of one of the singles: "I Should've Kissed You".

Otherwise Track 12 on the album, Stole My Heart. NEEDS A RELEASE

None of them

I can honestly say I agree.

Must say 'One Thing' is my guilty pleasure.

Stole My Heart is by faaaaar the best track on the album and they should release it, but i doubt they will becuase its a bonus track tis a shame, it woulda done them so well

Not exactly a wealth to choose from.

1st one was a good song though so that.

i thought they all had girlfriends

Think Perrie is a really good singer certainly in the context of a girl group. She is worth more that the I suspect casual interest of Zayn and certainly doesn't need any grief from his desperate fans.