[Miherasa]

I was watching the highlights and saw Caroline bitch about Luke A. Then I noticed for the first time she referred to him as "her" which is really nasty of her for a person who introduced themselves as male and a "he".

(lurker for more than a few years, first post, yay!)

[JB3]

Originally Posted by Miherasa

I was watching the highlights and saw Caroline bitch about Luke A. Then I noticed for the first time she referred to him as "her" which is really nasty of her for a person who introduced themselves as male and a "he".

(lurker for more than a few years, first post, yay!)

Hello, no she was talking about Shiv when she said 'her'

[wonkeydonkey]

Welcome! Someone else thought that this morning. It would be interesting to have it confirmed, as it is rather damning if true.

[Janey Jones]

As much as I dislike Caroline, she's not guilty of this one!

Referring to Shiv, she commented that "Luke A can't stand her".

I think some folk may have taken it as a stand-alone comment and heard it as: "Luke A, can't stand her".

Case dismissed

[hulakula]

Originally Posted by Janey Jones

As much as I dislike Caroline, she's not guilty of this one!

Referring to Shiv, she commented that "Luke A can't stand her".

I think some folk may have taken it as a stand-alone comment and heard it as: "Luke A, can't stand her".

Case dismissed

That's how I interpreted it too. They were having a conversation about Shivonne, so it would have made sense.

[wonkeydonkey]

IN that case, the odd thing is that it is Caroline whom Luke A gets on with badly, not Sheivonne; in any case it seems very unlikely that Luke has been confiding his thoughts about Sheivonne to Caroline.

[B L Zeebub]

Originally Posted by wonkeydonkey

IN that case, the odd thing is that it is Caroline whom Luke A gets on with badly, not Sheivonne; in any case it seems very unlikely that Luke has been confiding his thoughts about Sheivonne to Caroline.

I don't think anyone is claiming that Caroline was telling the truth!

[hulakula]

Originally Posted by wonkeydonkey

IN that case, the odd thing is that it is Caroline whom Luke A gets on with badly, not Sheivonne; in any case it seems very unlikely that Luke has been confiding his thoughts about Sheivonne to Caroline.

Yes, I thought it was odd too,they both seem dislike each other

I presumed that Caroline was subtly trying to get her to nominate Shivonne, by creating the impression that others were going to do the same thing.

[hulakula]

Originally Posted by B L Zeebub

I don't think anyone is claiming that Caroline was telling the truth!

Yes, I doubt she is

[Johnp_]

I took the "her" to mean Shievonne as they were discussing her, not Luke A.

[waking_state]

hehe this thread is funny. No but caroline calling Adam a gorilla got me very mad to start with! I cant make up my mind on her sometimes i love her and sometimes i hate her

[yellowlabbie]

Originally Posted by Pices-55

Well yes you did. miss one that is.

That means there's 3 then?

[Pices-55]

Originally Posted by yellowlabbie

That means there's 3 then?

Only 2 remaining. The second was removed.

[trevor tiger]

I must say I'm a bit astonished anyone mistook this let alone 3 ? posters and enough to start threads on it. It's as clear as anything can be to me because Caroline actually confirms it. She says . . can't' stand her . . . after a conversation about people not liking Shievonne and she is asked who and she confirms Luke A can't stand Shievionne