Originally Posted by doublefour:
“Another average Dalek story, in light of another thread around at the minute I may have included this as a suggestion. But I think it's below average!
I rarely highlight special effects or production values, but the Root things are embarrassing I couldn't show this to a non Doctor Who fan as it were for fear of being laughed at. Although having said that I do laugh when it attacks the Dalek and I will concede that is quite good!
The tests in the city remind me of the Pyramids of Mars and vice versa.
Overall though all the Dalek stories in Pertwee's era are all flawed and slightly average. Probably my worst story of Pertwee's final season also.”
Interestingly Robert Holmes openly acknowledges this in Pyramids by having Sarah say something like "Didn't we do something like this in the City Of The Exxilons?" It was smart of him to get that in before the fans started tutting. Holmes was actually the de facto script editor on Death To The Daleks whilst Terrance Dicks was whipping Monster of Peladon into vaguely useable shape, so that's probably why he remembered how similar the sequence was (or simply where he nicked the idea from...)
Personally I like Death To The Daleks. It's not clever, it's not the best made story, the effects are ropey at times and Pertwee seems a little distracted - but as he'd just made the decision to leave the show, and never liked Daleks anyway, that's probably to be expected.
There are lots of good bits though -
the Exxilons are terrific, great masks, well realised and lots of them too. The sand people in Star Wars always reminded me a bit of Exxilons.
The Daleks also look superb - a very snappy paint job. Pity they are on fairly obvious rails in the quarry location, but it does mean that they really zip about. And I like Michael Wisher's voices for them. Nasty and harsh of course, but a bit expressive too.
And the location work is terrific, a really good use of a sandpit. The planet, for once, seems large.
The story is a bit Terry nation by numbers. Space plague - check. Primitive planet with hostile roots - check. Someone called Tarrant - check... but it's engaging enough and the pace keeps the viewer interested.
OK, shame about the irritatingly out of place music, about the Dalek that beats itself up, about Jill Tarrant - surely one of the wettest female characters of the Pertwee era (and she's got some fairly stiff competition, not least from Queen Thalira in the very next story), and a shame about the poor modelwork of the city, which never looks like a genuine city, nor does it give any impression of scale. Doctor Who could do good modelwork - just look at the Dalek city on Skaro, which was way better than this, ten years previously.
So, a mixed bag - but my third favourite that season, after The Time Warrior and Planet of the Spiders.