Originally Posted by Cantona07:
“Your first paragraph can never be doubted. Despite my obvious anti-rangers agenda i really like the guy.
"Time will tell" though? Time has told. He is absolutely genuinely inept as a manager. Cast your mind back to when he was a player, did he seem like a manager in waiting? I know thats hardly conclusive proof of anything but he was already bucking the trend to pack up his media career to be a number two. I can see him being an effective number two to someone like Smith but the very concept of him as a manager just doesn't ring true. Once you have got past the "he gets respect cos he is a Rangers legend" i wonder what substance is actually left in managerial terms.
If the whole Rangers scenario hadn't blown up when it did Ally McCoist would have got the season after Smith in charge and then been quietly moved aside.”
Yes, a really likeabe guy who to me just should not be Rangers manager at all, indeed I doubt he should be a football manager at all..
Part of his very persona that nakes him likeable and a media natural must make it difficult for him to fully respected as a manager, no matter how much of a Rangers legend he is.
His ongoing public use as a manger of players' nicknames to me is a bit cringeworthy. You're the manager now, Ally.
He has been pretty brave to step away ftrom the media and put himself up for a job that he clearly wanted and no doubt thought he could do, if anticipating much better circumstances. And he has been .extremely loyal to a club he loves.
But no, the sooner he realises he's not up to it, probably the better for everyone, unless they are purely looking for Rangers downfall.