Originally Posted by
James J:
“A period soap would be interesting, but perhaps logistically difficult. Though if they built a period exterior set and such it would be possible.
Think Downton Abbey all year round. A serialised spin off perhaps, once or twice a week?
RobbieSykes would be emigrating!
”
A period soap which moved with the times could be the soap version of Ashes to Ashes where 'events' are actually in the show itself.
As long as it 'moves on' I think it could be great; not to mention you have historical events to promote every now and then and get people watching (good way to support your factual side too!).
Danger is a Heartbeat situation. Staying safe and in one time zone. A period drama with proper moving time would be difficult to manage, but not impossible if you have the right planning team and culture in place.
Not so much a Downton Abbey type, but you could have a show set in a working class neighbour hood and chose...any time you want in the last century or so.
It also makes the characters more real as like The Hour they can comment on contemporary events; unlike current soaps which are A-political and in a bubble universe.
Originally Posted by Glenn A:
“I know where you're coming from, but ITV's attempts at new soaps since the seventies have bombed. Indeed the only British soap launched since then to do well has been Eastenders and for a time Brookside, but this is long gone.”
The fact Brookside and Eastenders managed it shows there is some demand for them. ITV in its current state is a bit of a worry ofc (they could screw it up by putting Amanda Holden in a big role for example (they would wouldn't they?)) - but they've had successes in drama.
Personally I think theres room for it. They also still can manage huge ratings, launch if over BGT week instead of the Corrie run for example. Then go into a well advertised and specific slot for the rest of the time.
They have the means; and I think they need something like that to really help their consistency and also freshen the channel a bit (Millionaire and You've Been Framed really could do with being drop, especially the later).