Originally Posted by Dillyp:
“Superdooper, that is actually brilliant! So far Max has turned out to be everything you clever girls (and boys?) on the forum predicted: flaky, deceitful and willing to sink to all sorts of depths to protect his own interests. But also kind of likable to the unsuspecting, I mean, easy with people and funny. He knew exactly how to turn on the charm with Eddi, or at least what to do to get her onside. Just by watching how she interacted with Chrissie, he used the 'no love lost there, then' observation to press all the right buttons.
As for why Eddi fell for it so easily, well I think he just got lucky there: his humour is indeed like our Luc's (though imho not nearly so clever) so that could have struck a chord with her unconsciously without her being on her guard so much. And she did still ask 'why, who are you?' when he said he was just the locum and she did refuse his first suggestion of a drink together. I actually thought it was feasible that her guard was udown - yes, she's smart and tough and all those things, but she's just been incredibly hurt, she has to work with the mega-couple S+C and it's not that implausible that she is just feeling a bit vulnerable and liked having someone on her side again. The Sacha and Chrissie vs Eddi and Max team thingy was not a subtle device, but it was perhaps just what she needed at that u in time. Just some thoughts....
May I say, as a virgin poster, THANK YOU for opening up this thread. I always followed the mainstream HC one, but this is the one I most enjoy, because you anyway talk about the other characters and the episode, but you share my bias towards desperately wanting Luc back and for the Leddi fiasco to somehow end well! And I felt braver about joining in as it's now a smaller community (at least, I think it is!!). Hatz, need next chapter of your fanfic SOON.”
“Superdooper, that is actually brilliant! So far Max has turned out to be everything you clever girls (and boys?) on the forum predicted: flaky, deceitful and willing to sink to all sorts of depths to protect his own interests. But also kind of likable to the unsuspecting, I mean, easy with people and funny. He knew exactly how to turn on the charm with Eddi, or at least what to do to get her onside. Just by watching how she interacted with Chrissie, he used the 'no love lost there, then' observation to press all the right buttons.
As for why Eddi fell for it so easily, well I think he just got lucky there: his humour is indeed like our Luc's (though imho not nearly so clever) so that could have struck a chord with her unconsciously without her being on her guard so much. And she did still ask 'why, who are you?' when he said he was just the locum and she did refuse his first suggestion of a drink together. I actually thought it was feasible that her guard was udown - yes, she's smart and tough and all those things, but she's just been incredibly hurt, she has to work with the mega-couple S+C and it's not that implausible that she is just feeling a bit vulnerable and liked having someone on her side again. The Sacha and Chrissie vs Eddi and Max team thingy was not a subtle device, but it was perhaps just what she needed at that u in time. Just some thoughts....
May I say, as a virgin poster, THANK YOU for opening up this thread. I always followed the mainstream HC one, but this is the one I most enjoy, because you anyway talk about the other characters and the episode, but you share my bias towards desperately wanting Luc back and for the Leddi fiasco to somehow end well! And I felt braver about joining in as it's now a smaller community (at least, I think it is!!). Hatz, need next chapter of your fanfic SOON.”
Welcome to the thread
great first post good anaylsis of Eddi.Although i did like posting on the main HC thread, i do prefer this thread, mainly because everyone shares my love for Leddi but also everyones nice and friendly in here

I agree, Superdooper that is a brilliant comparison Max is very much a modern day Mr Wickham! But does that mean Max and Luc will have a history? I have said in the past it will be a bit cheesey if they know each other, and i still think this but anythings possible in holby land!







