Has anybody been able to get orange to offer any of 3's tariffs under their Orange Value Promise?

you cant on the ads it say on selected 02 t-mobile and vodafone plans

yes you can. I have 500 anytime mins for £25pm. you must be a long time contract holder. 2 years plus should be good enogh

It is possible to have some of 3's tariffs on Orange (more likely if you are out of your contract period though).

I called Orange and asked for my PAC code as I was considering moving network as Orange did not have the phone that I wanted. They asked what offers I had seen elsewhere. I mentioned 3 and they said I could have Select 500 (the Orange equivalent of 3's Videotalk 500) for £25. I didn't ask for the tariff.

I couldn't find any phone on any network that I really wanted and I didn't really want to leave Orange anyway. I decided to stick with Orange and have the Select 500 tariff but when I asked for the tariff they said that I would need to get a new phone and commit to another 12 months (which I had been told was not the case beforehand). I have no problem staying with Orange but I didn't see the point in getting a new phone just for the sake of it. So I am moving network (sadly).

Not sure why Orange wnt to tie me to a new contract which would involve them subsidising a new phone.

I managed to get videotalk 750 matched by saying i was leaving them for '3' network. (the guy from disconnections did say i was the last customer to get a '3' talk plain as he just receaved a memo while dealing with my call instruction that under no cercomstances is any '3' terif be matched as effective imediately) They did match the terifs for 2 weeks but droped them cos of looseing to much money.