[monrose]

There have been quite a few eliminations that angered me as I feel those people should not have been voted out so early. To get this thread started, I was real pissed off over the eliminations of Nicholas (Series 2), 4Sure (Series 3), Futureproof (Series 4), Austin Drage (Series 5), Aiden Grimshaw (Series 7) and The Risk (Series 8)

[nooneoo]

Sophie
The Risk
Kitty

[shaunnashines]

Austin
Laura White
Miss Frank
Sophie
The Risk

[LoveBug.]

Laura White's Fallin' performance still is one of my favourite XF performances ever! She shouldn't have left so early..

[LunarLegend]

Janet Devlin Although Janet was one of the most pimped contestants in the early stages infact I'd say 2nd most pimped with Frankie 1st her treatment in the live shows was unfair Im not going to count her going on last in the first week becouse it didn't make a difference as their was no voting every other week she was given bad slots apart from halloween week but even then the producers were still up to their tricks with the bad camara work for the first 20 seconds or so of the song you could hardly see Janet see looks like a dot on the stage the camara's were shot so far away from and thoughout the performace the camara's kept zooming in at the judges and the audience then when it comes to the key change of the song the camara's suddenly downards zoomed in on the screen on the stage not to mention the judges comments every week trying to put doubt in the mind of the viewers and it worked.


Craig Colton Unpopular opinion but I though he was really underrated one of my favourite contestants from series 8 like James I though Craig was better than Marcus I think the live shows ruined Craig, Gary said at judges houses that the attraction with Craig was that he is not a pop star and that is nothing but a good thing there is nothing I love more about talent shows than a live final with a wide variety of artists who are nothing alike he didn't get the best song choices he was great at judges his audition,bootcamp and judges houses and also in the first live show but after that I feel like every week his personality was just drained by dreary songs was sad to see him go as I thought he sang better than Amelia in the sing off and he had earned his place in the show.

Jamie Archer, Jamie was one of my favourite contestants from his series can't believe he has kicked out in favour of Lloyd Daniels however I didn't stay mad about this for long becouse Lloyd was only kept in as the producers thought he would be a credible act to lose to Jedward in the sing off and the only remaining finalist they could credibly save them over as not only was Lloyd not a great singer it would have been his 3rd time in the sing off so surprise surprise Lloyd gets the death slot after Louis Walsh giving an interview in the week saying he though Lloyd would be the next act eliminated Lloyd gets the goodbye speach comments from the judges the following night it all back fired and Lloyd was safe and the look on Simons face was priceless.

John Wilding Series 8 he could have won if he made the live shows and he was sent home over Frankie.

Paije Richardson Sabotaged by Abigall for not posting the results that week.

Misha B Bully gate enough said.

Mary Bryne Wasn't a fan but I hate sing off's in a top 5

Diana Vickers She lost out to Eoghan enough said.

Austin Drage Left before Eoghan and Daniel Evans.

Johnny Robinson He was sabotaged

James Michael Was far better than Marcus and Frankie

After reading this most people on here are going to think I hate X Factor I don't I just really like to analyse it. #XFactorNerd

[FanFromHolland]

Misha B

[LandslideBrad]

Miss Frank and Bad Lashes, they both had potential.

Also Cher Lloyd's elimination in the final, I excpected it BUT I voted so much for her and Will.I.Am was SO awful I didn't feel it was her fault.

[unclekevo]

Misha B purely because although I expected it, I thought that she was way better than either Marcus or Amelia in the semi-final.
Treyc Cohen - Sod It gate, enough said
Rachel Adedeji - Lloyd was awful, her sing-off however was great
Paije Richardson because he performed fantastically that night
Mary Byrne because there shouldn't have been a sing-off
James Michael because Frankie
Austin Drage mainly as I loved both him and Rachel Hylton and I thought the bottom two that night should have been Eoghan and Daniel
Sophie Habibis because Louis and Gary stitched her up and because her and Misha were way better than Janet, The Risk or Frankie that night.
G4, not so much an elimination but they were far better than Steve

[Shannon_Burnett]

Treyc Cohen and James Michael!

[Patti-Ann]

I was annoyed with Louis saying Jamie had 'big hair and a small voice' then voting him off over Lloyd

[jackbell]

Originally Posted by LunarLegend

After reading this most people on here are going to think I hate X Factor I don't I just really like to analyse it. #XFactorNerd

Not at all. Read and agreed with nearly, if not all of it.

[Kuda_Kunaka]

Treyc Cohen
Misha B
The Risk
Sophie Habibis

[EvilLlamaThingy]

The only one which I remember actually being annoyed after was when Lucie Jones went home instead of Jedward. There were other ones which I wasn't too keen on, like Laura White or Kitty, but I could still get the reasoning behind it.

[E05297535]

Misha B at the time....not now though, record deal and supporting Nikki M!!

G4 at the time....not now though, had a record deal (b4 split) and concerts galore!!

Miss Frank....they went too soon!!

Rachel hylton....her sing off was great but JLS was the golden boys by then!!

Mary Byrne......producers knew Cher had to stay and sacrifice Mary!

Wagner....fuming cos his mentor wanted him out too!! He was a trier to the end!!

Jedward....entertaining on the show, but they were up against Olly, sang better
...Not fuming now..got/had a record deal and made it to Eurovision too!!

Rowetta....the final should have been between her and G4 Imho!!

[troy4783]

Miss Frank they really should have stayed longer they had so much more to give
The Risk
Laura White Defintely should have stayed longer
Misha B should have defintely at least made the final

[Satanel]

I think all of: Brenda Edwards, Nikitta Angus, Alisha Bennett, Ruth Lorenzo, Rachel Adedeji, Treyc Cohen and Misha B should have made it further in the competition, even though some did manage to make third or fourth place anyway; it's not enough in my books.

[unclekevo]

Originally Posted by Satanel

I think all of: Brenda Edwards, Nikitta Angus, Alisha Bennett, Ruth Lorenzo, Rachel Adedeji, Treyc Cohen and Misha B should have made it further in the competition, even though some did manage to make third or fourth place anyway; it's not enough in my books.

Hmm, there's something really similar about quite a few of those acts, I can't think what though

[mashitup]

Diana Vickers
Rowetta

[InMyArms]

Originally Posted by mashitup

Rowetta

Rowetta was actually eliminated on my 13th () birthday! I remember I got back from my birthday party and found out - I wasn't pleased! It's weird to think I was 12 when I first started watching this show - now i'm almost 21!

[itsJoe]

Laura White & Mischa B, They're great singers and fair to Mischa is doing quite well for herself but I hope Laura is doing good too!

[Transponster]

My main one is Paije leaving over Cher after giving one of the best sing-off performances ever.

[InMyArms]

Originally Posted by Transponster

My main one is Paije leaving over Cher after giving one of the best sing-off performances ever.

I could never really take a liking to Paige because he reminded me of the big vegetable character from Wizadora on the left of this screenshot. I never liked that character as a child.

[rickster1995]

one that i can think of that actually left me really angry was Treyc's just purely because of whether you thought there was nothing special about her she was a typical diva singer she completely slayed katie in that singoff and katie messed up, i wonder if treyc had just sat on the stage and went "sod it" would she have been put through... it was actually at that moment (took me 7 series to realise) that this show is not a singing competition.

[Sun Tzu.]

Frankie Cocozza.

Last years winner is illegitimate.

[smuckle01]

Series 6 - Lucie, even more so than any other elimination
Series 7 - Aiden
Series 8 - Sophie and Kitty