• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • TV Shows: UK
Citizen Khan - BBC One
<<
<
8 of 47
>>
>
15 minutes
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by Grouty:
“The daughter in the gold trousers is fit ”

Originally Posted by SuperSal1:
“Unbelievably bad. Can anyone give one redeeming feature in this crap?”

The above is the answer for what is directly below

One tweet on Twitter was pondering how many men would be looking for the actress on twitter....


https://twitter.com/BhavnaLimbachia

SarahK
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by Terry Wigon:
“The worst attempt at a PC sitcom was (in my opinion) that Jasper Carrott one where he was married to (I think) Meera Syal. That was set in Brum too but it was worse than this, I think. I think the characters may be likeable in this once you get into it and suspend disbelief at the OTT accents, etc.”

That was called 'All About Me'. You are right about how bad it was!
Lizaj
28-08-2012
I'd be prepared to watch again. Yes it did seem a throw-back comedy and maybe we are all so fed up with cozy middle class sit coms and supposedly clever series that many are enjoying On the Buses etc on 10. There were one or two mildy funny situations and a fair bit of cringyness .
I liked well-spoken mum as she shows up Mr pomposity..wasn't that the point?
I loved Little Miss Demure who of course was nothing of the sort. I think her deviousness was funny (although like a previous poster , I did think of poor Shafilia Ahmed ) and also noticed how beautiful she was in her hijab let alone her gold kecks. I loved Khan's reaction to Dave and Dave himself. It certainly isn't high brow and of course comedy doesn't have to be successful. I feel like giving it a chance on the grounds that I like at least three characters and want to see how they develop.
Stansfield
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by harrypalmer:
“The toilet rolls and sofa in plastic wrap are common to ordinary working-class culture too (maybe more so in the past), so I fail to see how that is an Asian twist on things.

I'm getting the feeling that someone wanted to rewrite 1970s style sitcom and remove the inherent racism from that period. It didn't work.

Goodness Gracious Me extracted all these jokes out of Indian culture in the 1990s, it's been done. And before anyone goes on a rant about how Pakistani culture is different, they'd do well to explain why the jokes are about exactly the same things.”

When I saw the rolls, all I could think of was Bend it like Beckham...from 10 years ago...as for CK; RIP BBC comedy...
Prince Monalulu
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by spottybanana10:
“I loved Little mosque on the Prairie!!! never did get round to seeing how it ended though”

Oh never heard of that., google is my friend, so is a certain download site...
stud u like
28-08-2012
Sparkle this and Sparkle that. I needed a translator.

It wasn't until I saw the credits that I discovered some place called Sparkhill.

You learn something new everyday.
Prince Monalulu
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by Inkblot:
“No.

Some may be saying that it's funny on an observational level, if you're from a Pakistani background you'll recognise the characters. But if you don't recognise the characters you're left with the same formulaic comedy about a pompous, self-important middle-aged man that we've seen many times before since the 1960s if not earlier. If what's different this time is that he's a pompous, self-important middle-aged Pakistani man then that's hardly groundbreaking multicultural comedy, is it?”

How many people know a Basil Fawlty, Hycinth Bucket, Victor Meldrew?
Lots of people seemed to enjoy CGM despite not being Asian, but they got the humour in the characters.

I didn't watch too much of it, found it a bit cringey, but hey ho it's formulaic, that's not a reason in and of itself to ditch something.
Someone's going to like it, it's just not for you and probably not for me either.
Then again I rarely LOL in real life at anything, even programs I do find amusing.
Prince Monalulu
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by stud u like:
“Sparkle this and Sparkle that. I needed a translator.

It wasn't until I saw the credits that I discovered some place called Sparkhill.

You learn something new everyday.”

Bugger me, I'd have thought the context would have been a clue, but maybe not for you.
kochspostulates
28-08-2012
I watched China - A culinary adventure - documentary about one type of Asian and then this comedy about another kind of Asian and the difference between the two shows was so massive.


I would be so annoyed if I was a British Pakistani
Hassaan13
28-08-2012
Still puzzles me about the fact that they get Indian actors/actresses to play Pakistani characters (if Wikipedia is to be believed, Adil Ray is British Pakistani), as with the majority of the characters in this series.
Prince Monalulu
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by kochspostulates:
“I watched China - A culinary adventure - documentary about one type of Asian and then this comedy about another kind of Asian and the difference between the two shows was so massive.


I would be so annoyed if I was a British Pakistani”

Dear lawd, what kind of daft criticism is that, what's your point.
China, and Pakistan thousands of miles away, hugely different cultures, the the latter is shot through the dual prisms of British comedy, then the influences of 40 plus years of immigration.

Yes the differences are massive, it's totally your fault if you thought there was going to any kind of common theme between the two.
myss
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by Belligerence:
“Little Mosque on the Prairie, now that had the right blend of comedy.”

Oh my goodness, I thought that was a clever pun on words, not an actual comedy! I hope it was a good one, the title alone had me giggling.
zoepaulpenny
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by LostFool:
“I made myself watch about 10 minutes but I didn't titter or smile once. One of the unfunniest things I have seen in many years.”

have to agree, it was dire.. crap at it's best.
kochspostulates
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by Prince Monalulu:
“Dear lawd, what kind of daft criticism is that, what's your point.
China, and Pakistan thousands of miles away, hugely different cultures, the the latter is shot through the dual prisms of British comedy, then the influences of 40 plus years of immigration.

Yes the differences are massive, it's totally your fault if you thought there was going to any kind of common theme between the two.”

No I mean one show was really good and one was really rubbish. I know they were different kinds of shows, but they could have taken a few production values from the other one and made this one better.
superboy
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by Ambassador:
“Is it funnier if you live in a multicultural area such as London or Bradford (serious question)

Maybe the whiteness of Northumberland makes the humour pass me by”

Yes

I live close to Sparkhill, many of the jokes you won't understand unless you're a local/live in similar areas
Inkblot
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by Prince Monalulu:
“How many people know a Basil Fawlty, Hycinth Bucket, Victor Meldrew?”

Probably not that many nowadays. They were funny in their day and as a snapshot of Britain those shows are still enjoyable but I don't think they represent the lives of most British people in 2012. So to have a Mr Khan who's like a 1970s sitcom character is a bit odd. Unless we're being told that British Asians in Birmingham are still living in the 1970s.
Prince Monalulu
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by kochspostulates:
“No I mean one show was really good and one was really rubbish. I know they were different kinds of shows, but they could have taken a few production values from the other one and made this one better.”

You're just compounding one confusing 'point' with another if you ask me, but I'm not getting into it.
Just say it was poor, crap or whatever.
DavetheScot
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by trunkster:
“Oh yes they will, it's probably written by a leftie Guardian reader. It's unfunny because it's trying so hard to be PC and inoffensive. Cringeworthy PC garbage of the highest order.”

Now that's a criticism that surprises me. I knew a lot of people would dislike it and find it unfunny, but the one thing it really, really isn't is PC.

I can't help suspecting some people think that a programme that contains anyone with a brown skin is automatically "PC gone mad".
DavetheScot
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by 15 minutes:
“The above is the answer for what is directly below

One tweet on Twitter was pondering how many men would be looking for the actress on twitter....


https://twitter.com/BhavnaLimbachia

”

I preferred the other daughter (though both were lovely)
googleking
28-08-2012
Have I fallen asleep and woken up in 1973?
Itsnotreal
28-08-2012
What a pile of crap this show is....when was this pitched to Bbc ...in the 70's to appeal to who?
Cherry-choc
28-08-2012
Originally Posted by JohnnyForget:
“No belly laughs, but amusing in places and definitely not as bad as many as saying.

Tbh I actually prefer it to a few other comedies that I don't find even remotely funny, but others seems to love, i.e. "The Royle Family", "Gavin and Stacey" and "Two Pints Of Lager And A Packet Of Crisps".

One poster said that "Citizen Khan" has no redeeming features. I disagree. It has one important redeeming feature:- Keith Lemon's not in it.”

All of this. Hopefully it remains non-PC and the wife tones it down a bit.

Get the feeling that minority comedies are viewed through a harsher prism and get almost no leeway.
alcockell
29-08-2012
Originally Posted by Cherry-choc:
“All of this. Hopefully it remains non-PC and the wife tones it down a bit.

Get the feeling that minority comedies are viewed through a harsher prism and get almost no leeway.”

Nope - it's just that we saw enough of that 70s-era shite back in the 70s...
vauxhall1964
29-08-2012
Originally Posted by Cherry-choc:
“All of this. Hopefully it remains non-PC and the wife tones it down a bit.

Get the feeling that minority comedies are viewed through a harsher prism and get almost no leeway.”

the commissioning of this dud and its greenlighting for broadcast are what's PC about it... the actual dire 'comedy' is just plain awful whatever the style.
Prince Monalulu
29-08-2012
Originally Posted by DavetheScot:
“I can't help suspecting some people think that a programme that contains anyone with a brown skin is automatically "PC gone mad".”

Seems to cover it, one popped up earlier Guardian readers won't like it, the other one claims it's written by a Guardian reader.
Start with premise then look for evidence to support it. or start with premise and talk guff.
<<
<
8 of 47
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map