[gladiator18]

Jasmine said that Rhian was telling her that Julie was bitching about her, and she said this when the mics were off(didnt know they did this). Rhian did this when she knew it couldnt be shown on tv, imo she tried to make Jasmine start an argument with Julie so that it looks bad on tv, and therefore she'll get evicted, this rhians a sly one. And I thought that Rhian was so scared of Jasmine that she was too scared to even get her clothes out(wth) and yet she has a nice conversation with her and even tries to be her best friend by telling her who really likes her and who doesnt, this just doesnt add up.

[Kewpee]

I think Rhian just wanted to hurt Jasmine. Fair enough I suppose, but it doesn't make her look good, whether what she said was true or not.

[Pontywarrior]

She told her the truth!

[zx50]

And of course, Jasmine is/was telling the truth. Hmm...

[gladiator18]

Originally Posted by Pontywarrior

She told her the truth!

Why do it when the microphones switched off? thats the bit i dont get

[vanzandtfan]

Originally Posted by gladiator18

Jasmine said that Rhian was telling her that Julie was bitching about her, and she said this when the mics were off(didnt know they did this). Rhian did this when she knew it couldnt be shown on tv, imo she tried to make Jasmine start an argument with Julie so that it looks bad on tv, and therefore she'll get evicted, this rhians a sly one. And I thought that Rhian was so scared of Jasmine that she was too scared to even get her clothes out(wth) and yet she has a nice conversation with her and even tries to be her best friend by telling her who really likes her and who doesnt, this just doesnt add up.

It doesn't add up because we have no idea of the context of the conversation. Was the discussion initiated by Rhian or Jasmine? Did Rhian say it in a calculating manner, or was she lashing out at something Jasmine had said to her.

We've already seen that Jasmine has a way of taking the truth of a conversation and spinning it into something completely different, and as long as she remains the source on what was said we'll never really know what happened.

Having said that, if you want someone to blame for it not adding up, don't blame Rhian or Jasmine, but blame BB for turning the mics off.

[samhainapples]

Hopefully at some point she'll deliberately sabotage the sound equipment in order the criticise the Situation to another HM. Then we can legitimately all sing:

Watch her wreck the mike
Watch her wreck the mike
Watch her wreck the mike
Psych!

[Pontywarrior]

It doesn't really matter in what context it was said, Rhian told the truth, Julie had been 2 faced about things.

Rhian said it off mike as it was a private conversation.

I'm not sure why Rhian is being bad mouthed here?

[Penny Crayon]

Wasn;t it off mike in the taxi when they went shopping?

[queserasera]

Originally Posted by Pontywarrior

It doesn't really matter in what context it was said, Rhian told the truth, Julie had been 2 faced about things.

Rhian said it off mike as it was a private conversation.

I'm not sure why Rhian is being bad mouthed here?

Maybe because that is just Rhian's take on things

And the people who are "bad mouthing" her see it differently

ie she wasn't telling the truth but distirting it and julie wasn't two faced but being considerate and diplomatic

[Pontywarrior]

Originally Posted by queserasera

Maybe because that is just Rhian's take on things

And the people who are "bad mouthing" her see it differently

ie she wasn't telling the truth but distirting it and julie wasn't two faced but being considerate and diplomatic

She was telling the truth as we have seen how Julie is.

[gladiator18]

Originally Posted by Pontywarrior

It doesn't really matter in what context it was said, Rhian told the truth, Julie had been 2 faced about things.

Rhian said it off mike as it was a private conversation.

I'm not sure why Rhian is being bad mouthed here?

Haha since when is anything supposed to be private in the BB house. I dont get why they turn the mics off? Why didnt she tell her when the mics were on?

[JVS]

Previous experience should have told Rhian not to say anything to Jasmine that can be used against you.

[queserasera]

Originally Posted by Pontywarrior

She was telling the truth as we have seen how Julie is.

No that is your interpretation of how Julie is.

As I genteelly tried to point out other opinions are available, and some of them are the polar opposite of yours

[Skyrah]

Originally Posted by Penny Crayon

Wasn;t it off mike in the taxi when they went shopping?

yup, Jas said it was while they were on the shopping trip out of the house, so of course their mics would be switched off while traveling to Morrisons

[taratia123]

rhian didnt tell her when the mics were on as she was stirring it and doesnt want to ruin the role she is playing.she would also have liked jas to have a go at julie.

[zx50]

Originally Posted by JVS

Previous experience should have told Rhian not to say anything to Jasmine that can be used against you.

Jasmine's about as trustworthy as Caroline was in Big Brother 13.

[Phyllis Stein]

Originally Posted by zx50

Jasmine's about as trustworthy as Caroline was in Big Brother 13.

Don't think Rhian is much better.

[BabelBrook]

Originally Posted by taratia123

rhian didnt tell her when the mics were on as she was stirring it and doesnt want to ruin the role she is playing.she would also have liked jas to have a go at julie.

Or altenatively she told her in the taxi when she knew they could have a conversation without Julie or anyone else interrupting.