Originally Posted by Steve Williams:
“
Yeah, but as mentioned BBC1 is far more competitive on a Sunday now than they have been in the past. In the mid-nineties of course they were awful and that was with a schedule of Lovejoy, Birds of a Feather and another drama, Lovejoy was thrashed by Heartbeat and Birds was thrashed with You've Been Framed. The 9pm dramas were usually beaten by ITV as well and it was only the odd programme that did anything - like Keeping Up Appearances and even then they had to shuffle around the schedules and shove fillers like Hotshots in to give it a decent chance. For a while a Sunday night slot would be the kiss of death for a BBC show.
BBC1 is unique in being able to show big factual shows and I think this is the best decision they could have made. Countryfile is a hit show, there's no denying that and when Strictly returns you'll get BBC1 winning the early evening, without wasting appealing programmes.”
Heartbeat was the cause of a lot of BBC1's 1990s Sunday problems. I know BBC1 had had a few Sunday ratings whippings from other things before that, such as
Darling Buds of May in spring 1991, which became a massive success thanks in no small part to facing opposition such as London Marathon highlights and a
Two Ronnies compilation's third screening, in its first few weeks; and
'Allo 'Allo got whipped in early 1992 because it was clapped out by that time, but when
Heartbeat took up an autumn residence in 1993, after a successful spring run, BBC1 started making less of an effort on Sunday nights...
In 1994, they dropped from two new autumn sitcoms to one, and started showing early 1980s
Last of the Summer Wine episodes instead, and showed a reduced number of
Lovejoy episodes, and they had odd start times such as 7.10pm.
Then in 1995, we got two sitcoms back, but only for ten of the sixteen weeks of the autumn season, and no early evening drama at 7.30pm.
1996 was worse still with six episodes of
Pie in the Sky, and six of the seven episodes of
The Legacy of Reginald Perrin as the highlights of the early evening schedule. And ITV added
Coronation St into the mix that autumn, to make BBC1 even less inclined to schedule very much of their good stuff.
And so it went on, and the problems spread to the rest of the year. There'd still be a handful of good sitcoms or dramas on early Sunday nights over the course of each year for the rest of the 1990s, but they'd often be isolated, and there'd sometimes be several weeks with no pre-watershed comedy. And all sorts of things were turning up by the end of the decade:
Wildlife on One, Wildlife Special (new and repeats), one-off docusoap update programmes, various antiques programmes,
Ground Force and a spin-off.