Originally Posted by AlexiR:
“It doesn't look great.
I'm not sure if this is because I've lived through the British version for so many years but The X Factor US continues to feel incredibly stilted and dated. Even from a US perspective it just feels as if they've dumped the bog standard American Idol auditions in front of a crowd. The more I see the more I understand why NBC aren't shying away from it with their scheduling. It also feels telling that basically none of these clips or promos focus on any of the talent on the show. And you're right Britney doesn't come across as a particularly natural or engaging television presence. Demi Lovato comes across quite well in those (and other) clips though.
Sticking with The X Factor US Simon Cowell has been going into defensive mode about the clash with The Voice next week. He's described it as 'dirty tricks' blamed The Voice creators for pushing the scheduling after Britain's Got Talent beat The Voice in the UK and then a few sentences later blamed Christina Aguilera for trying to overshadow Britney (and apparently Britney will be devestated by this turn of events). Its a very different tone from what we're used to hearing. Could Mr Cowell be a little worried?”
Those "sneak peeks" did very little for me. Britney looked reserved and at times uncomfortable, although I did like when she did say to that douche in the second clip "Who let you on the stage?" Perhaps Britney might bring more than what I just saw from those clips. Alternatively, I will be quite worried about the future episodes if those are the best moments from Britney. Doubt it though. Demi shows promise as a judge and don't hold back, which I liked. It will be amusing should we see more bantering between her and Simon. Other than that, I didn't find it surprising that talents were not featured. Maybe they haven't found that special, undiscovered act yet. Not that that will outweigh the appearance of Britney and Demi.
Speaking of TXF vs The Voice, I think The Voice will dent TXF, but not win the slot. There are so much hype and publicity around the new judges that curiosity factor will win over. That is how ABC's Revenge and Body of Proof (March premiere/season 1, 2010-11 season) last year managed to premiere with better than expected numbers. Sure both had lead-ins but nevertheless did a good job. Simon should really learn to suck it up and deal with it. He should be grateful that they have big names on the panel, otherwise the anticipation for season 2 will be nowhere as big as they do now. However, after the initial weeks, when they get to bootcamp and live shows and their ratings happen to plummet, who/what will Simon target next? Modern Family (Wed/ABC) and TBBT (Thu/CBS)? The two sitcoms managed to beat TXF last year, they will most likely do it again this year, if the Britney/Demi publicity fades. As for The Voice, their move is a risky one. The spinning chair gimmick is already done and they used their Superbowl lead-in card. Moreover, there has been no contestant/artist success stories from the two seasons aired so far (Then again, were there any successful models from the 18 cycles of Top Model? CW is currently airing the 19th cycle and this time, the viewers opinion also factors in).