• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • Doctor Who
Most Attractive Doctor
<<
<
1 of 3
>>
>
Wopsy
10-09-2012
Through the years, we have witnessed a variety of Doctors, each bringing their own charm to the role. But it is rarely discussed which Doctor would win in the attractiveness and fanciability stakes. The obvious choice would be to plump for model esque Matt Smith, but I don't think he is necessarily the most fanciable...

William Hartnell brought a grandfatherly cool to the role, an older statesman air. Not pysically stunning, but for an older gent he was in good shape when it came to battles, had a mane of soft hair and a good bone structure.

Patrick Troughton could be deemed as somewhat cute and cuddly. His impish allure would win over a few hearts, in the way that Dudley Moore might have done. His moppish hair makes him a rival for the likes of The Beatles.

Jon Pertwee was the heroic type. Despite greying hair, he was definitely the hunkiest Doctor to date. A brilliant wardrobe, masculine body and effortless charm. You can imagine he would dine you well and be a superb entertainer at the dinner table and in the bedroom.

Tom Baker is an odd one. Somewhere between good looking and not. His curly hair is a delight and the broad grin could melt many hearts, but is he fanciable in the same way as Pertwee? Whereas Pertwee looked like he would smell fresh, Baker's attire gave him an instant musty air. This is a turn off for me.

Peter Davison is conventially good looking with a soft face and a schoolboy esque haircut. He is the kind of man you would enjoy a cosy meal with, the kind of man who wouldn't overstep the mark. While good looking, he does lack the edge and bad boy factor though which makes him all too safe. The kind of man you would end up cheating on.

Colin Baker has a great physical presence about him. Strong manly features and a confidence which would draw you in. His height adds stature, but is let down by the curly blonde hair. Had it been cropped and spikey like the twins from Bros and he had been clad in denim, he would have been a real heartthrob.

Sylvester McCoy is a curious one. Not instantly attractiveness, but he does have a certain something. The way he scampers about in an animal like way is cute and he brings an understated sensuality to the role.

Paul McGann is effortlessly sexy. Dashing in a Mr Darcy way. He merely has to glide into a room for the pulses to start racing.

Christopher Eccleston brings a bad boy charm to the role. Although not facially overwhelming, his attire and cropped hair give him the edge that makes him desirable.

David Tennant is a good looking man, fine hair, good build, atheletic and confident to go with it. But this is all too obvious. He needed some flaws, like a hooked nose or wandering eye. When someone is so perfect, one starts to look for faults that aren't there which can be dangerous.

Matt Smith might be lanky and gangly, but he has luxurious hair and a beautifully sculptured face which would win over any model agency, This Doctor manages to recapture some of the dandy appeal of Pertwee. His slightly camp nature makes him more accessible for males too.
nebogipfel
10-09-2012
Jon Pertwee was indeed "entertaining in the bedroom". He sang sea shanties and played accordian.

http://www.retrobloke.com/more/on/details/09231
Granny McSmith
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by Wopsy:
“
David Tennant is a good looking man, fine hair, good build, atheletic and confident to go with it. But this is all too obvious. He needed some flaws, like a hooked nose or wandering eye. When someone is so perfect, one starts to look for faults that aren't there which can be dangerous.
.”

I often wonder just what it is that DT needs to make him perfect - this is it!

(Edit - forgot to say, hello Wopsy, welcome to the forum. )
Collins1965
10-09-2012
For me, hands down it has to be David Tennant. Funny thing is, he is most attractive as 10, not himself, or any other character I have seen him play.

Its something about the twinkle in his eye, the sheer joy and boyishness he portrays as 10 - utterley butterly

And sorry, Granny, I don't think he needs a hook nose or any other "impediment" to improve his looks - he is just perfect as is
Dizx
10-09-2012
In the non-photoshopped corner, we have David Tennant, http://www.insidesocal.com/modernmyt...nant-specs.jpg, but in the photoshopped corner, we have Matt Smith with eyesbrows http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lz...145no1_500.jpg I'm torn...
Actually having seen the lovely David in person I'm going to say him. Woo, boasting, sorry.
I like this thread, got to look at Tennant and Smith pictures for post research
Granny McSmith
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by Collins1965:
“For me, hands down it has to be David Tennant. Funny thing is, he is most attractive as 10, not himself, or any other character I have seen him play.

Its something about the twinkle in his eye, the sheer joy and boyishness he portrays as 10 - utterley butterly

And sorry, Granny, I don't think he needs a hook nose or any other "impediment" to improve his looks - he is just perfect as is ”

My post was meant to be ironic.

I absolutely agree with you. I think the Tenth Doctor is about as perfect as it is possible to be.

(DT as himself is less attractive, though still very nice.)
alienpanda
10-09-2012
Matt Smith - 1000%

He's very striking looking, and has a great Physique (ex-footballer I beleive)
JohnnyForget
10-09-2012
The most attractive Doctor in "Doctor Who" was Doctor Grace Holloway, closely followed by Doctor Martha Jones.
mousy
10-09-2012
Just no to David Tennant

Kind of small and ratty



I like my men like men (although I did love Peter Davidson in his day)

edited as I feel a bit mean saying that about david tennant
Collins1965
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by Granny McSmith:
“My post was meant to be ironic.

I absolutely agree with you. I think the Tenth Doctor is about as perfect as it is possible to be.

(DT as himself is less attractive, though still very nice.)”



The irony went by me but glad you still think DT needs no improvement
nebogipfel
10-09-2012
It was ironic?

*cancels appointment for hook nose and wandering eye cosmetic surgery*
CoalHillJanitor
10-09-2012
At Troughton's age he was less a rival for The Beatles than for the likes of Moe Howard or Ish Kabibble.
Matt_Aspden
10-09-2012
8th Doctor was blooming GORGEOUS....as is Paul McGann....I'd love to travel with him!!

But 11th Doctor is very tasty too. Matt Smith is adorable.

I'll take both.

Now.

cat666
10-09-2012
From a male perspective, if I could look like any of the Doctors, it would be 8. Just for the hair.
korbany
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by cat666:
“From a male perspective, if I could look like any of the Doctors, it would be 8. Just for the hair.”

Paul wore a wig for that, if I'm not mistaken.
CoalHillJanitor
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by korbany:
“Paul wore a wig for that, if I'm not mistaken.”

So it's available, then.
daveyboy7472
10-09-2012
Joanna Lumley.

CoalHillJanitor
10-09-2012
Why didn't Nebo say Alice Roberts?
SillyBillyGoat
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by Wopsy:
“Matt Smith might be lanky and gangly, but he has luxurious hair and a beautifully sculptured face which would win over any model agency, This Doctor manages to recapture some of the dandy appeal of Pertwee. His slightly camp nature makes him more accessible for males too.”

As a gay guy myself, "camp" people do nothing for me. I think Matt is the most attractive Doctor, but I don't think he's slightly camp.
nebogipfel
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by CoalHillJanitor:
“Why didn't Nebo say Alice Roberts? ”

Just in case Mrs Nebo reads it.
CoalHillJanitor
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by nebogipfel:
“Just in case Mrs Nebo reads it.”

Mrs Nebo's a doctor then?
Abomination
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by SillyBillyGoat:
“As a gay guy myself, "camp" people do nothing for me. I think Matt is the most attractive Doctor, but I don't think he's slightly camp.”

There's a difference between camp and effeminate. I'd say Matt Smiths portrayal of the Doctor is very slightly camp, in a Captain Jack Sparrow sort of way.
For me, he's definitely the most attractive Doctor.

I find Tennant boring to look at... he has no defining facial features really and although attractive, I also think he's very overrated.
nebogipfel
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by CoalHillJanitor:
“Mrs Nebo's a doctor then? ”

ooh. no, she's not. good point. That can be my get out.


Dr Alice Roberts is a damn fine woman, er, I mean Doctor. There, I've said it.
Shrike
10-09-2012
Originally Posted by JohnnyForget:
“The most attractive Doctor in "Doctor Who" was Doctor Grace Holloway, closely followed by Doctor Martha Jones.”

Mmm - what about Dr. Liz Shaw?
Mulett
10-09-2012
A few years ago, I was eyeing up a GORGEOUS man in Covent Garden, as he walked by hand in hand with his equally gorgeous girlfriend.

He was wearing casual clothes and his hair was tucked into a baseball hat. He had the most beautiful dark eyes.

I then recognised his girlfriend. She had been in my favourite TV show, Doctor Who. The Girl in the Fireplace to be exact. I then realised that, in real life, the actress from that story was dating David Tennant.

And just as they passed me by, I realised the gorgeous man I had been eyeing up was, indeed, David Tennant.

I so would!
<<
<
1 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map