Originally Posted by soulmate61:
“Lay year somebody suggested Harry's music fans were so numerous that his win was a foregone conclusion.
What are the respective sizes of Girls Aloud and Westlife fanbase?”
If that was the case, Danny from McFly would have won Popstar to Operastar. McFly are not as huge as they used to be. Dougie from McFly was a shock winner of I'm a Celeb just before Harry won, and I presume that part of the reason was that people didn't want Mark Wright to win and voted for Dougie instead after he made it that far and Fatima left. We don't get statistics released for Strictly, but Dougie was never on top of the vote for IAC until the very end.
I would say the size of Westlife's fanbase is similar, but not completely as they're Irish. McFly have been around for almost 10 years now, and unbelievably both Girls Aloud and Westlife have passed that mark. I don't think Kimberly will have a Cheryl Cole type following though, so we can't conclude that she'll make it to the end if shes an OK enough dancer.
Its also different with Westlife and Girls Aloud because they've both split up where as McFly haven't. Well, I think Girls Aloud went on a 'break' for a year that has just kept extending. Neither have released anything as a group for a while I don't think, when as McFly did have a hit with 'Shine A Light' within a year of the show.
At the end of the day nobody is going to win this show without being a talented enough dancer. We shall see.