who do you want in the lives?

jkcutex · 18-09-2012, 15:41

which 12 do you want on the live shows, that's 3 from each category, for me it would be

girls
______
Melanie mccabe
Lucy spraggen
jade eilis

boys
______
James Arthur
starboy Nathan
joseph

overs
_______
Caroline Poole
Melanie massing
kye

groups
__________
times red
gmd3
mk1

remember this is who you like not who is for now.

David_Morgan · 18-09-2012, 15:45

I think that Joseph Whelan is 26 and so Overs. They might, perhaps should, change the upper limit as they did with Matt Cardle

Satanel · 18-09-2012, 15:46

Girls: Melanie McCabe, Sharon Rose...
Boys: Joseph Whelan...
Overs: Melanie Masson, Carolynne Poole...

are who I want. I don't care for any of the groups and can't remember enough of them to fill each category.

EdgarK · 18-09-2012, 15:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by David_Morgan

I think that Joseph Whelan is 26 and so Overs. They might, perhaps should, change the upper limit as they did with Matt Cardle

Pretty sure I remember it was announced before the series started that the age limit this year would be 28.

jkcutex · 18-09-2012, 15:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by Satanel

Girls: Melanie McCabe, Sharon Rose...
Boys: Joseph Whelan...
Overs: Melanie Masson, Carolynne Poole...

are who I want. I don't care for any of the groups and can't remember enough of them to fill each category.

can't remember Sharon rose??

jkcutex · 18-09-2012, 15:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by David_Morgan

I think that Joseph Whelan is 26 and so Overs. They might, perhaps should, change the upper limit as they did with Matt Cardle

maybe well I'd switch him with Melanie then and don't know which boy I'd add

if age hasn't changed.

EdgarK · 18-09-2012, 16:10

Hmm...

Girls Lucy Spraggan, Sharon Rose, Lauren Smith
Boys Taylor Breslin, George Shelley, Eddie String
Overs Robbie Hance, Melanie Masson, Kye Sones
Groups Poisonous Twin, Times Red, MK1

Doubt it would win the ratings war, but I promise I'd take my seat on time every weekend

millysshaw · 18-09-2012, 16:18

Quote:

Originally Posted by jkcutex

can't remember Sharon rose??

They only showed a tiny bit in a segment the weekend before last. If you look on you tube. you should be able to find her. I liked her hope she makes it to the lives.

I also liked Robbie from last weekend so hope he makes it, dont know what catagory he would fall in.

David_Morgan · 18-09-2012, 16:19

Quote:

Originally Posted by EdgarK

Pretty sure I remember it was announced before the series started that the age limit this year would be 28.

I hope you are right - there are a few good boys on the cusp and a wealth of great overs.

Carlisle156 · 18-09-2012, 16:26

Girls
Britt Love
Lucy Spraggan
Salena Mastroianni

Boys
Matt Defreitas
Jahmene Douglas
Adam Burridge

Overs
Carolynne Poole
Kye Sones
Melanie Masson

Groups
GMD3
Duke
Mia & the Moon

LunarLegend · 18-09-2012, 16:31

Girls
Ella Henderson
Jade Collins
Leanne

Boys
Jahmene Douglas
Rylan Clark
Starboy Nathan

Overs
Carolynne Poole
Melanie Masson
Christopher

Groups
I don't mind as long as GMD3 don't get though.

LandslideBrad · 18-09-2012, 16:38

I might have spelling errors/I don't know some of their last names but...

Girls
Melanie McCabe
Sharon Rose
Lucy Spraggan

Boys
Jason Viet Tien
Rylan Clarke
Starboy Nathan

Overs
Carolynne
Melanie Masson
Robbie

Groups
Duke
Times Red
A super group

David_Morgan · 18-09-2012, 16:40

Girls
Amy Mottram
Ella Henderson
Lucy Spraggan

Boys (if limit is 28 as suggested earlier)
Jahmene Douglas
Joseph Whelan
Robbie Hance

Overs
Melanie Masson
Kye Soame
Christopher Maloney

Groups
Duke
MK1 (-1

)
Rough Copy

I doubt that this lot would appeal to the main target demographics though.

staceyxxx23 · 18-09-2012, 18:51

Girls:
Megan O'Neill
Tasha Pyne
Charlotte Reavey

Boys:
Rylan Clark
Jake Quickenden
Adam Burridge

Overs:
Carolynne Poole
Joseph Whelan
Eddie String (Idk whether he'd be an over or not, but I can't think of anyone else anyway).

Groups:
MK1
Times Red
Poisonous Twins

hannah · 18-09-2012, 19:01

Girls
Ella Henderson
Lucy Spraggon
Melanie McCabe

Boys
Adam Burridge
Jahmene Douglas
James Arthur

Overs
Carolynne Poole
Kye Sones
Melanie Masson

Groups
GMD3 (as long as they are in the live shows im not bothered who the other groups are)

beckham76 · 18-09-2012, 19:06

Quote:

Originally Posted by staceyxxx23

Girls:
Megan O'Neill
Tasha Pyne
Charlotte Reavey

Boys:
Rylan Clark
Jake Quickenden
Adam Burridge

Overs:
Carolynne Poole
Joseph Whelan
Eddie String (Idk whether he'd be an over or not, but I can't think of anyone else anyway).

Groups:
MK1
Times Red
Poisonous Twins

stacey... im now begining to think your louis walsh.. on here pretending to be someone else!!!
ryalan and poisonous twin!

staceyxxx23 · 18-09-2012, 19:10

Quote:

Originally Posted by beckham76

stacey... im now begining to think your louis walsh.. on here pretending to be someone else!!!
ryalan and poisonous twin!

Must admit that Louis Walsh has fabulous taste (with the exception of Wagner, tehe).

beckham76 · 18-09-2012, 19:17

Girls: should be!!!

Melanie McCabe
Ella Henderson
Sian Phillips

Boys:

Joe Cox
jahmene Douglas
James Arthur

overs:

Robbie Hance
Carolynne Poole
Melanie Mason

groups!
will coment after the manufactured groups been done!

Chris Malony (wildcard pick) i wouldnt choose him in my top 3.. but i have put tenner on him to win at 25-1 witht he rumours he made show!!!

WeekendDude · 18-09-2012, 20:46

Girls

Amy Mottram
Jade Collins
Lucy Spraggan

Boys

Jahmene Douglous
James Arthur
Jake Quickeldon

Overs

Carolynne Poole
Melanie Masson
Christopher

Groups

GMD3
MK1
Mixed Group

09beyoncefan · 18-09-2012, 20:53

Girls
Ella Henderson
Lucy Spraggan
Jade Ellis
(would love Amy Mottram and Jade Richards too)

Boys
Nathan
Kye (he is a boy not an over right?)
Jahmene

Groups
MK1
Poisonous Twin (if only for Steph from BB9 haha)
GMD3 (although they'll get annoying as time goes on I think)

Overs
Melanie Masson
Carolynne Poole
Hayley Evetts

Fiercefanatic · 18-09-2012, 21:01

(I know that what I want is never gonna happen though, but these are the desrving ones IMO)
Girls:
Sharon Rose
Leanne Robinson
Melanie McCabe

Boys:
Starboy Nathan
Jahmene Douglas
Jason Viet Tien

Overs:
Carolynne Poole
Melanie Masson
Hayley Evetts

Groups:
MK1
Poisonous Twin
GMD3

beckham76 · 18-09-2012, 21:15

Quote:

Originally Posted by WeekendDude

Girls

Amy Mottram
Jade Collins
Lucy Spraggan

Boys

Jahmene Douglous
James Arthur
Jake Quickeldon

Overs

Carolynne Poole
Melanie Masson
Christopher

Groups

GMD3
MK1
Mixed Group

interested why you would picl jade collins... she sounded awful on her audition, even Gary told her off.. she forgets the lyrics at bootcamp... very surprising choice..

tvmad999 · 18-09-2012, 21:37

BOYS
Jahmene Douglas
Starboy Nathan
Jake Quickenden

GIRLS
Ella Henderson
Lucy Spraggan
Melanie McCabe

OVER 28's
Carolynne Poole
Kye Sones
Melanie Masson

GROUPS
GMD3
MK1
A Group formed by the judges after bootcamp

_NiallDEE_ · 18-09-2012, 21:38

Girls

Melanie McCabe
Leanne Robinson
Madeleine Wilson

Boys

Jahmene Douglas
Joseph Whelan
Jake Quickenden

Overs

Melanie Masson
Carolynne Poole
Kye Sones

Groups

MK1

can't even think of any other groups that I liked

WeekendDude · 18-09-2012, 21:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by beckham76

interested why you would picl jade collins... she sounded awful on her audition, even Gary told her off.. she forgets the lyrics at bootcamp... very surprising choice..

she sounded amazing. SHE is ONLY 17 and has loads of potenital. All four judges loved her if you watched their facees. And in fact Gary loved jade's voice, all he said was that she didnt warm up for the high notes which isnt even bad, he obv knows that she can hit them.....it is a very nervous thing to do. And no actually its Jade Ellis who messes her lyrics up at the start of her performance

18-09-2012, 15:41	#1
jkcutex Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 222	who do you want in the lives? which 12 do you want on the live shows, that's 3 from each category, for me it would be girls ______ Melanie mccabe Lucy spraggen jade eilis boys ______ James Arthur starboy Nathan joseph overs _______ Caroline Poole Melanie massing kye groups __________ times red gmd3 mk1 remember this is who you like not who is for now.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

POPULAR SEARCHES ON DS

On Digital Spy

who do you want in the lives?

Digital Spy

Network

Help

Search Digital Spy

18-09-2012, 15:45	#2
David_Morgan Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 550	I think that Joseph Whelan is 26 and so Overs. They might, perhaps should, change the upper limit as they did with Matt Cardle

18-09-2012, 15:46	#3
Satanel Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2010 Location: North East, England. Services: Ruth Lorenzo. Posts: 10,540	Girls: Melanie McCabe, Sharon Rose... Boys: Joseph Whelan... Overs: Melanie Masson, Carolynne Poole... are who I want. I don't care for any of the groups and can't remember enough of them to fill each category.

18-09-2012, 16:10	#7
EdgarK Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2011 Posts: 887	Hmm... Girls Lucy Spraggan, Sharon Rose, Lauren Smith Boys Taylor Breslin, George Shelley, Eddie String Overs Robbie Hance, Melanie Masson, Kye Sones Groups Poisonous Twin, Times Red, MK1 Doubt it would win the ratings war, but I promise I'd take my seat on time every weekend

18-09-2012, 16:26	#10
Carlisle156 Forum Member Join Date: Nov 2010 Location: Berkshire Posts: 12,590	Girls Britt Love Lucy Spraggan Salena Mastroianni Boys Matt Defreitas Jahmene Douglas Adam Burridge Overs Carolynne Poole Kye Sones Melanie Masson Groups GMD3 Duke Mia & the Moon

18-09-2012, 16:31	#11
LunarLegend Inactive Member Join Date: Jun 2012 Posts: 3,452	Girls Ella Henderson Jade Collins Leanne Boys Jahmene Douglas Rylan Clark Starboy Nathan Overs Carolynne Poole Melanie Masson Christopher Groups I don't mind as long as GMD3 don't get though.

18-09-2012, 16:38	#12
LandslideBrad Forum Member Join Date: May 2012 Posts: 3,254	I might have spelling errors/I don't know some of their last names but... Girls Melanie McCabe Sharon Rose Lucy Spraggan Boys Jason Viet Tien Rylan Clarke Starboy Nathan Overs Carolynne Melanie Masson Robbie Groups Duke Times Red A super group

18-09-2012, 16:40	#13
David_Morgan Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 550	Girls Amy Mottram Ella Henderson Lucy Spraggan Boys (if limit is 28 as suggested earlier) Jahmene Douglas Joseph Whelan Robbie Hance Overs Melanie Masson Kye Soame Christopher Maloney Groups Duke MK1 (-1 ) Rough Copy I doubt that this lot would appeal to the main target demographics though.

18-09-2012, 18:51	#14
staceyxxx23 Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: with cher lloyd. Services: #TeamRylan. Posts: 9,430	Girls: Megan O'Neill Tasha Pyne Charlotte Reavey Boys: Rylan Clark Jake Quickenden Adam Burridge Overs: Carolynne Poole Joseph Whelan Eddie String (Idk whether he'd be an over or not, but I can't think of anyone else anyway). Groups: MK1 Times Red Poisonous Twins

18-09-2012, 19:01	#15
hannah Forum Member Join Date: Oct 2008 Posts: 2,774	Girls Ella Henderson Lucy Spraggon Melanie McCabe Boys Adam Burridge Jahmene Douglas James Arthur Overs Carolynne Poole Kye Sones Melanie Masson Groups GMD3 (as long as they are in the live shows im not bothered who the other groups are)

18-09-2012, 19:17	#18
beckham76 Guest Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 1,473	Girls: should be!!! Melanie McCabe Ella Henderson Sian Phillips Boys: Joe Cox jahmene Douglas James Arthur overs: Robbie Hance Carolynne Poole Melanie Mason groups! will coment after the manufactured groups been done! Chris Malony (wildcard pick) i wouldnt choose him in my top 3.. but i have put tenner on him to win at 25-1 witht he rumours he made show!!!

18-09-2012, 20:46	#19
WeekendDude Forum Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Posts: 75	Girls Amy Mottram Jade Collins Lucy Spraggan Boys Jahmene Douglous James Arthur Jake Quickeldon Overs Carolynne Poole Melanie Masson Christopher Groups GMD3 MK1 Mixed Group

18-09-2012, 20:53	#20
09beyoncefan Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2009 Posts: 549	Girls Ella Henderson Lucy Spraggan Jade Ellis (would love Amy Mottram and Jade Richards too) Boys Nathan Kye (he is a boy not an over right?) Jahmene Groups MK1 Poisonous Twin (if only for Steph from BB9 haha) GMD3 (although they'll get annoying as time goes on I think) Overs Melanie Masson Carolynne Poole Hayley Evetts

18-09-2012, 21:01	#21
Fiercefanatic Forum Member Join Date: Sep 2012 Posts: 1,010	(I know that what I want is never gonna happen though, but these are the desrving ones IMO) Girls: Sharon Rose Leanne Robinson Melanie McCabe Boys: Starboy Nathan Jahmene Douglas Jason Viet Tien Overs: Carolynne Poole Melanie Masson Hayley Evetts Groups: MK1 Poisonous Twin GMD3

18-09-2012, 21:37	#23
tvmad999 Forum Member Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 1,103	BOYS Jahmene Douglas Starboy Nathan Jake Quickenden GIRLS Ella Henderson Lucy Spraggan Melanie McCabe OVER 28's Carolynne Poole Kye Sones Melanie Masson GROUPS GMD3 MK1 A Group formed by the judges after bootcamp

18-09-2012, 21:38	#24
_NiallDEE_ Forum Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Posts: 9,856	Girls Melanie McCabe Leanne Robinson Madeleine Wilson Boys Jahmene Douglas Joseph Whelan Jake Quickenden Overs Melanie Masson Carolynne Poole Kye Sones Groups MK1 can't even think of any other groups that I liked

POPULAR SEARCHES ON DS

My DS Account

On Digital Spy

who do you want in the lives?

Digital Spy

Network

Help

Search Digital Spy