I'm sorry but she cannot sing. And she bites Alex Turner's style.
This is a singing competition.. Or meant to be.

No way is she going to make it outside this show. Who's going to want to hear her when they can listen to alex who sings better and looks better?

We had this bs with frankie

She's a joke.`

Agreed she is utter crap along with the whole patronising show , they are clearly attempting to con the viewers into thinking she is something special , not fooling me.

She wont win, however, if she get's through to the live shows or not, imo, she has a contract, loads of people (on facebook ect) luv her and want her to bring out more songs, I really like her, yes she can't sing, but nither can Elton John, and look how well he has done, different things and all that, think she will make it big out of this show.

shes better than a lot of them, funny that nobodys complaining bout Eddy String or the essex guy.

When did an unknown last have a top 10 single and sell six thousand albums in a couple of days on the back of one TV performance?

And why do her haters have to be so darned offensive about it? I really can't think she vexes you any more than the umpteenth vacuous fake American vexes me.

I have to agree.

There is nothing special nor original about her and her vocals are average at best. I've got nothing against her as an artist and I wish her success, but she's just not my thing but I just don't GET everyone acting like she is some kind of super-genius? It seems fake to.

I guess you either love her or hate her? They want everyone to love her though. They want to turn her into a cash-cow.

Wrong.

She's like a singing Pam Ayres.

i just dont like the special treatment she receives, she got to sing her song choice from the list provided.. which obviously wasnt very good.. otherwise they wouldve shown a clip..
then she gets to sing 1 of her own songs.. which is unfair and unprecedented! there is other songwriters left in the comp.. and im certain they couldve wowed the judges too..

not to mention the fact she is still here she should be watching it on tv with the rest of us after group stage at bootcamp!


all this aside she is a very talented song writer.. anybody who doisnt think this is wrong.. haha cos im right!!

This is a competition to find a recording artist. Both of her original songs so far have been excellent. Tea and Toast in particular was poignant and beautiful written. I would buy her album tomorrow, she's fantastic.

They are also garbage.. If you are talking about the Katie Price lookalike.. I'm not familiar with Eddie String.

I'm pretty sure they didn't get standing ovations. Also if your trying to imply Lucy's rubbishness is being pointed out because she's a woman, your wrong. Frankie Cocozza got dragged for his WTFery.

Edgar, iam American. Also what's so American about "straight up".. The words are in the English dictionary isn't it not? When I came over here, people were saying it.. I thought nothing of it.

Well said. I suspect those fms who get their kicks being nasty are just jealous of her obvious talent.

is she a man?

Yay!!!!!!

go buy it... its on sale now!

tea and toast is a great songwriting... but 1 of the most depressing songs ever written! wouldnt want it on my walkman!! my age might be given away there!!

Just saw the ad on facebook, off to buy it right now. Really sad, but gorgeous song.

What talent? I can talk sing too.. You won't catch me going on any type of singing or talent show.. Now I do like the uk, but I really can't find anywhere else in the world in recent memory where a performance like that is given a SO.

Is that meant to be a criticism? If Lucy is as witty as Pamela Ayres, we have a star.

I wonder if you would have recognised Alex Turner's talent if he had turned up playing solo with his guitar?

She's this years Katie/Cher/Danyl with all this love her/hate her thing going on

Not a fan myself by the way - I don't like 'Victoria Wood' type songs

I'm not going to call her garbage but she is basically a Victoria wood rip off and is going to do the same thing every week which is already boring the hell out of me.

He wouldn't turn up on a show like this.

Disagree. Think she's fantastic, think you're just flat out wrong in saying she's not talented, and look forward to seeing her in the live shows