Well let's hope. Would be tragic if she didn't get through.

I can't see it as she didn't make judges houses.

Since she isn't in the final 6 its not gona happen

Aaaawwwww crap! Forgot Amelia Lily actually got to judges houses first.
Doh.....

its a shame, she was much more likeable than most of the other girls. Maybe she can get a proper recording contract instead

How many times has she tried out for the X Factor now? 3 or 4 times? She should probably get the hint now...

Glad to see some love for magic Mel..

im gutted as not only has she gone but i dont like any of the others really! out of the 24.. i love Duke but they have zero chance of going through now they have :Louis!
like Ella.. but she isnt melanie.. so im never going to fall in love with her..
and Carolynne.. do really like her.. shame about the fake sob story but hey i forgive her... be astounded if she dosnt make the lives now she has Gary!
like james Arthur and Adam... but its going to be 1 from 2 we them.. so truth of matter is come the live shows im going to have 2 maybe 3... and were at JH now.. if someone was gonna grow on me going into the lives it wouldve happened by now!!

just hope Melanie gets signed up and makes the best of the oputunity.. cos lets face it you dont have to be a rocket scientist to realise she was vocally better than anything on the show this year...