Originally Posted by Charles II:
“No, what I meant is that there are no metal traits whatsoever for it to be even deemed "Metal" it'd be like calling Coldplay "nu-folk".”
Wrong, imo. There are loads of non downtuned metal that was born from the nu metal sound and producers.
One example. Roots by Sepultura. (produced by Ross Robinson, the Phil Spector of nu metal. Guest performances included members of Korn)
It was all just metal at one point. It took a few years before the likes of Kerrang pinned the name "nu metal" on these acts. In fact, it happened right when Limp Bizkit's Significant Other was released.