It felt very nostalgic seeing Sharon (in spite what I've sid about her in the past) and Cheryl on tonight's show - however brief.

When Cheryl said "I'd like to have seen it" (regarding someone's audition) it really felt like she was missing being part of the show. I'd like to see her return next year. And there is a great chemistry between Louis and Sharon.

If next year is the last, I'd like to see this panel.

I think that would be a great panel seen a lot of love for Sharon and Cheryl on twitter tonight think a lot of people miss them .

That would be an amazing panel.

Sharon's face would surely melt under the studio lights.

Are there rumours of x factor ending next year then?

I think the show's moved on form Sharon now and anyway I really like Tulisa and think she suits the X Factor very much. What About Cheryl joining Gary and Louis? I like Cheryl and think Nicole's a waste of space, we really need someone to replace her.

That would be a good panel.

I have to say, that panel could be just the rocket up its backside XF needs! Plenty of comedy between Louis and Sharon and Gary and Chezza gel. Yeah I know it shouldn't be about the judges, but when there's little chemistry it's dull!

Sharon time has long gone she has no idea what sells

I agree the chemistry between Louis and Sharon is great fun to watch. I don't get what Cheryl would bring to the party though.

I would love Gary, Louis, Cheryl and Sharon next year!

I agree totally !!! I really felt that tonight was a rehearsal for a change in panel next year.

Gary, Cheryl, Mrs O and Louis would be a fabulous foursome in my opinion.

Two firm sets of friends there.... the banter and chemistry would be perfect.

i'd prefer danni to sharon.

Perhaps more to the point, it would seem ridiculous to me if she genuinely hadn't.

That panel would absolutely guarantee its demise.

I do feel that whoever gives in from dani or cheryl could return next year if not it would be mel b replacing nicole. That would be the only change I feel

I'd actually love that, I wasn't the biggest fan of Cheryl on the show but seeing her tonight made me realise how much I miss her

Replace Gary with Simon and it would be the perfect panel.

I would prefer it if Sharon or Cheryl was replaced with Danni

Thats how to get people to stop watching. Put that thug Cole on the panel. What she knows about singing you could write on the back of a stamp!!!!

Cant they just replace Nicole with Sharon now !!! the x-factor is soo dull now! i cant stand nice fake people aka Nicole ... Sharon will add that much needed comedy and that life x-factor needs right now! .... plus it would be a good Pr trick !!

I love this idea. Very very much.

Tulisa is hardly Snow White. Belonged to a violent gang who would snatch handbags, lost her virginity at 14 (nearly lost it at 12) - these are her words from her book.

Enough people stopped watching last year, the panel needs a complete revamp. If Cole replaced Tulisa, I wouldn't really care, I wouldn't miss her.

Simon and Dannii coped ok

You'd think Shazza was the only judge to have had cosmetic surgery Louis is another one who looks remarkably line free too.

That would be a great panel but I do really love Tulisa.

Na , Sharon is as pointless as Louis. If she was on the panel the two of them would just gang up on the other two as they used to against Simon.