i said i missed Cheryl being on the panel in another thread..And some poster on here gave a :yawn: reply

Sharon, Gary, Cheryl and Simon would be great, Louis is too predictable now, he's simply been there too long.

Sharon will never be back she does not have a clue. Her time was a long time ago

I like it how it is. I don't think there should be any changes apart from Gary it'd be nice if he left and was replaced by Sharon. Tulisa, Sharon, Louis and Nicole would be a very interesting line-up.

I'd love this panel.

Sharon and Mel B could be hilarious and explosive too, hasn't Sharon slagged off Victoria Beckham in the past? They'd either bond because of it or be firm enemies!

Louis, Sharon, Mel B and Simon would be the ultimate panel imo.

Sharon and Louis yeah Cheryl and Gary no, dont mind gary i can tolerate him but Cole noway sorry.

yeah that sounds good to me.

Don't think Mel B and Sharon is a good mix ...

I think next year's series could be the last and I think Simon would like to return to make sure it goes out with a bang.

I can see him finally persuading Cheryl to return and I would love Sharon to come back.

Simon,Cheryl,Louis and Sharon as judges would be TV Gold.

I once suggested a double panelled Simon, Sharon, Louis, Danni vs.Gary, Tulisa, Nicole, Cheryl with old contestants that never made the top three having another go - perhaps with some new acts as well.

You could have Sugababes and Mutya Keisha Siobhan as the guests....

That would be the best panel they've ever had. Imagine Mel B & Sharon disagreeing!!

What, a screaming match between judges whilst the act is on stage thinking "This is supposed to be about me!" No ta...

Hopefully there wont be a show in 2013 for this gruesome foursome to appear on.

Maybe by then there will be some more interesting TV to be had on a Saturday night.

How about a panel of Ronan Keating, Guy Sebastian, Natalie Bassingwaithe and Mel B?

Guy Seb... who?

I'm actually fine with the Louis, Tulisa, Nicole and Gary panel after seeing this video of Nicki Minaj cussing Mariah Carey:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=apqPz...layer_embedded

A damn mess

i want to see a westlife member in the show...

I wouldn't mind that at all actually. Preferably Shane or Nicky though

I think Sharon might come back , depending on how well Nicole does, but I can't see Cheryl coming back sadly , maybe as a guest mentor or something though.

No, Gary needs to go.

Simon, Sharon, Cheryl and Louis?

Simon, Tulisa, Cheryl and Louis?

I'd rather have Danni than Cheryl back but I doubt she'd do it if Sharon was.

Can't bear Sharon or Cheryl, so that would be an instant turnoff for me.

My dream panel would be Gary, Dannii, Nicole and Will Young.

That said, until they improve the editing, get rid of the live audience at audition and boot camp (including cheering whenever anyone sings in tune), and actually let the judges make decisions, the show won't get any better.

If they refuse to see the real problems with the show, they could have the surviving members of Pink Floyd as the panel and it would still lose to SCD.