Were all brilliant tonight. Hooray.
Lucy, Jade, Melanie and Jahmene...
I like all of these, but tonight - Jahmene was good, Lucy was OK and Melanie and Jade were a bit meh, for me. All should be safe though as Kye, Chris and Dismal 3 were very bad.
Originally Posted by David_Morgan:
“I like all of these, but tonight - Jahmene was good, Lucy was OK and Melanie and Jade were a bit meh, for me. All should be safe though as Kye, Chris and Dismal 3 were very bad.”
“I like all of these, but tonight - Jahmene was good, Lucy was OK and Melanie and Jade were a bit meh, for me. All should be safe though as Kye, Chris and Dismal 3 were very bad.”
Agreed on Dismal 3 and Chris...
Surely the bottom two?
I dont think Melanie and Jahmene were up to Lucy and Jade's standard but they were all above average.
Originally Posted by LandslideBrad:
“I dont think Melanie and Jahmene were up to Lucy and Jade's standard but they were all above average.”
“I dont think Melanie and Jahmene were up to Lucy and Jade's standard but they were all above average.”
Someone else who liked Lucy? I assume we're a dangered species...
Originally Posted by Neomysterio:
“Someone else who liked Lucy? I assume we're a dangered species... ”
“Someone else who liked Lucy? I assume we're a dangered species...
”
She's not my usual cup of tea but thought she was good tonight
Originally Posted by Neomysterio:
“Someone else who liked Lucy? I assume we're a dangered species... ”
“Someone else who liked Lucy? I assume we're a dangered species...
”
Haha it seems like it, I didn't like her at her audition and at judges houses but she's been really really good on the live shows! Especially last night, I would already buy her album.
i think putting lucy in the same category as the very talented jade, melanie and jahmene is laughable. each to their own and all, but no, lucy is embarrassingly talentless.
Originally Posted by borintimebrenda:
“i think putting lucy in the same category as the very talented jade, melanie and jahmene is laughable. each to their own and all, but no, lucy is embarrassingly talentless.”
“i think putting lucy in the same category as the very talented jade, melanie and jahmene is laughable. each to their own and all, but no, lucy is embarrassingly talentless.”
Lucy isn't a great vocal and she may not be everyone's cup of tea. However, to say she is talentless is absolutely ridiculous. She is probably one of the most musically talented in this year. It was embarrassing to read something so uninformed.
Originally Posted by CARA2000:
“Lucy isn't a great vocal and she may not be everyone's cup of tea. However, to say she is talentless is absolutely ridiculous. She is probably one of the most musically talented in this year. It was embarrassing to read something so uninformed.”
“Lucy isn't a great vocal and she may not be everyone's cup of tea. However, to say she is talentless is absolutely ridiculous. She is probably one of the most musically talented in this year. It was embarrassing to read something so uninformed.
”
to reiterate my opinion, she's not just talentless, she's EMBARRASSINGLY talentless.
millions of people over the country can strum a few chords on a guitar, it's no signifier of talent. until she busts out a carlos santana or jimi hendrix cover her talent remains to be seen.
anybody with basic literacy skills can put together the childish rhyming couplets she comes out with, evident by the 'write a lucy spraggan song' thread on this forum. a passing GSCE in english is no proof of talent.
she can't sing for toffee, clearly. certainly no talent in that category.
she hasn't danced on the show, so unless she secretly has the moves like jagger or michael jackson or that sampson kid that won britain's got talent a few years ago, it seems she has no talent in that area either.
all in all, pretty clearly embarrassingly talentless.
Originally Posted by borintimebrenda:
“to reiterate my opinion, she's not just talentless, she's EMBARRASSINGLY talentless.
millions of people over the country can strum a few chords on a guitar, it's no signifier of talent. until she busts out a carlos santana or jimi hendrix cover her talent remains to be seen.
anybody with basic literacy skills can put together the childish rhyming couplets she comes out with, evident by the 'write a lucy spraggan song' thread on this forum. a passing GSCE in english is no proof of talent.
she can't sing for toffee, clearly. certainly no talent in that category.
she hasn't danced on the show, so unless she secretly has the moves like jagger or michael jackson or that sampson kid that won britain's got talent a few years ago, it seems she has no talent in that area either.
all in all, pretty clearly embarrassingly talentless.”
“to reiterate my opinion, she's not just talentless, she's EMBARRASSINGLY talentless.
millions of people over the country can strum a few chords on a guitar, it's no signifier of talent. until she busts out a carlos santana or jimi hendrix cover her talent remains to be seen.
anybody with basic literacy skills can put together the childish rhyming couplets she comes out with, evident by the 'write a lucy spraggan song' thread on this forum. a passing GSCE in english is no proof of talent.
she can't sing for toffee, clearly. certainly no talent in that category.
she hasn't danced on the show, so unless she secretly has the moves like jagger or michael jackson or that sampson kid that won britain's got talent a few years ago, it seems she has no talent in that area either.
all in all, pretty clearly embarrassingly talentless.”
I'd have to disagree with that - she's very creative.
