Originally Posted by Rhumbatugger:
“Great post Lovesy, but I seriously disagree with this part.
Zainab has always mocked and denigrated Masood when he's not 'strong' - over Syed after the reveal etc. She was always at him.
He has NEVER been respected properly by Zainab who has treated him dreadfully, many times.
I remember him crying at the mosque, worried that Syed's 'fall' might really hurt Zainab, and feeling like he now had to choose to support Zainab at the expense of his son and crying about it.
Mas isn't Yusef, he's complicated and has been massively manipulated, lied to and let down. He tries to 'man up' and that gets him nowhere either. Mas struggles all the time and I'm not surprised he's deeply resentful at Zainab, after being so terribly frightened for her and Kamil and not being believed. He's not a saint.
You're right though that that is all mixed up with Syed, but I still think that, ultimately, Mas loves them both. He just can't deal with it all.
As Tam said for Mas ( it cut straight to him) he's second string even to his wife (some such).
I hate the way Mas acted tonight, but Syed has been monumentally annoying, and he STILL took the money off his mother and NEITHER of them were honest with Mas.
It's horrible for all of them.”
Hi Rhumba

I think you took my bit in bold a little out of context, or else I didn't explain it/cover it very well. BIB - I totally agree, in the sentence before the one you bolded in my post, I said that Zainab had treated Masood appallingly, i wasn't excusing her in this, a lot of it is about the way the two of them work/don't work together, which is why I put that sentence in there, directly before the comments I made about Masood. Masood feeling jealous and resentful of Syed from when he was born, this is obviously to do with his relationship with Zainab, not about Syed at all, who was obviously a tiny baby then. The point I was trying to make was that we've seen Zainab very low, seen her have very little respect for herself, and realise some of the mistakes she has made. I agree, not all, not by a long way. She is damaged. We saw all this in particular during the aftermath of the Yusef stuff, her sense of self and esteem at rock bottom.
I've never got that Masood has recognised his own failings separately. I don't know, maybe I'm forgetting something? The closest I can remember is that he has recognised and spoken about how he has gone along with Zainab too many times, that he has let her be the way she is, encouraged her even, but again, this is more about Zainab, and still not really about him. I think he has failings that aren't just to do with Zainab, that are to do with his own psychological make-up. He always comes across like a martyr to me, full of his own self-importance. He judges his family's mistakes (and they have made many I know, and treated him horrendously at times too), judges them as people, as if from some high, righteous standard that he has. When his own mistakes have been monumental too.
Of course Mas isn't Yusef. I'm sure it was never his intention to hurt anyone, Syed or Zainab, he has been incredibly hurt by them himself. But even, when as you say, he has shown care and emotion for Syed, and for Zainab too, to me it still seems to come from a place, where it is on his terms, where it is about his 'higher' position in the family, about how he feels about himself as head of that family. I'm not saying he didn't genuinely feel concern and emotion to them, to him he did, but it always seems in relation to him, how it affects him, rather than real, unconditional, love and concern. I'm not sure if I'm explaining this very well. Yes, he has shown trust towards Syed, but then it always comes across to me like, 'look at me, the big man, I'm going to place my trust in you, look how good I am to do this, now don't let me down.'
Syed has to take reponsibility for his own actions, his own behaviour, and not blame others, he was dishonest, let others think they were responsible, tried to get out of it, there were no excuses for that. He did that last night I felt. At some point I would like to see Masood genuinely take reponsibility for his own failings and actions that have affected others too, to show some fundamental humility and not seem so pious. I know he apologised in the AB for what he said to Syed, the way he treated him regarding his sexuality, but this is so much more than just about Syed's choices and his sexuality.
We can understand why Syed is the way he is, but not excuse him. We understand how the way his parents have treated him, his own personality and how he feels about himself has led to this. At the same time we can understand that how Zainab has treated Masood has affected him too, has played a big part. But we cannot excuse him either, he is his own man, responsible for his own mistakes. Syed has been the one at fault in this situation of course, and Zainab to a lesser degree. Masood was not in the wrong here. But there are greater underlying issues that have led them all to this point, even if it was Syed's conscious actions that caused this current crisis, which he knows and has accepted responsibility for, but for no more than he should.