Your post makes no sense Lu and you didn't answer my complaints about the thread anyway. I am bisexual thank you very much, and the only actor people on here actually KNOW is closeted, Luke Evans.i thought it would be interesting to discuss someone who we have PROOF about, not pulling names out of hats. I think he is a great actor but find it sad he can't be open. But calling me a troll because I point out how absurd it is to doubt every relationship is immature.

You may want hot guys to be gay but that doesn't mean it's fair to say they are with no proof. Seems pointless too, as if it means you will have more chance anyway If someone told you that you were lying about being gay then you would hate it, so why do you think you have the right to say someone in a heterosexual relationship is lying when you have no insight into their life and therefore no reason to doubt them?

Anyone telling someone they are living a lie is extremely insulting to me, no matter what their sexuality. As I said, if you only believe someone when they say they are gay or bi and not when they say they are straight it is hypocritical. That is a fact.

Or do you really think some random person on the internet saying a stranger is gay has more weight than their own relationships? That couldn't be more unfair of them and shows you have an agenda. Some of Jenny Meadows reasons for doubting people are the most ludicrous things ever that is also something anyone using logic can see.

Anyway, I guess we should agree to disagree. Maybe I should leave you guys to randomly list celebrities if that's what you find fulfilling but you know I am right about it being hypocritical!

No need to say sorry. It's better for you if you don't read the offensive comments on the thread

Dec has dumped Ashley for his manager - guess he is straight then

Never believed the rumours of Dec being gay

I think there is something in the speculation about Nick grimshaw and Harry styles (cue OUTRAGE at suggesting a 1D member might be gay) - the Brits thing is just a bit odd - go to the toilet together (are they 17 year old girls?) but coming back separately is weird. Apparently Nick was "properly snogging" Matt Richardson so make of that what you will.

To refute these oh people are just wishful thinking claims can I make it absolutely clear that I find Harry an abhorrent little creature and hate Nick with a passion so there is definitely no wishful thinking on my part (also I'm female...) and I know that there is no PROOF but there we go. I wouldn't be at all surprised if there was something going on there.

The recurring, obvious showmances
Best mates with an openly gay guy nearly twice his age

Harold is gay but is too straight acting to market as 'the gay one' so will remain closeted for years, maybe forever

Just my opinion

^^^ Who's Harold?

Personally I don't think there's something going on between Harry and Nick, I just think it's a weird friendship (very weird). Not because Harry's in 1D etc. or anything like that, I just think they're mates.

And doesn't Matt Richardson have a girlfriend (yes, I know that's not proof, but still)? And even if he is gay, I'd like to think he can do bet than Grimmy *shudders*.

I think they go to the bathroom to do drugs. A blind item suggested it once.
I think Harry is bi, and I don't think he's in a relationship with Nick.

I am not sure but I still have hope Nathan Sykes is gay. Always get a vibe but no proof.

Think he is cute. Might have a crush *blushes*.

He just seems to come across as different to the rest of the wanted. I think all these thing that the other boy say about him like all the girls he bedded and something about a porn star once are just blown up and made to make it look like he is a bad boy when really he not. It's odd. I am not sure if this is to cover something up or it's just to make he out to be a bad boy. But I tell you if my "mates" were make me look like a slag I would have something to say.

This whole nariana relationship that he come out of seemed so forced to me. Looked fake. They only kiss when they knew a camera there. I think it was to give them profile which was all made up and planed by their "manger" (who is a prick). So I don't believe that to be evidence he is straight.

I know he has said in the past he was not gay but that was when he was 17. I don't know, there is something odd about it all and I don't think it's all to do with me thinking he is hot. I am not sure. Is he just a good straight guy made to look bad, Does he act good to stop looking bad or is it something else? What do you all think?

(Yes I know your not bothered, So just skip this comment. Thanks)

Might have to do with um... snow. You know, white powder

Based on what though? Nothing. Pretty depressing that in his day and age people still think being friends with a gay man means you must be gay yourself. That in itself is rather closed minded and bigoted.

You basically just admitted you think he might be gay because you have a crush in him I have been there in the past, the projecting....

Yes I said about the crush. What I don't get is why there is there a conflict of stories. Something don't add up. Looking back I am not the only one that think this. To much hard work to prove he not gay.

I think Harry would probably dabble both ways. The fact a lot was made of his openness to nudity and the like of Mary Byrne saying he would wander round having conversations with anyone in the house makes me think he's not someone who wouldn't be up for trying pretty much anything.That plus the fact that all the rumours of him with different types and ages of females makes me think he's a free spirit

This is very true



Also, genuinely didn't know Nick Grimshaw was actually gay

Nope, it really isn't hard work. But if that's what you want to think... Personally I don't think he is good looking anyway, but it's your fantasy

you just like winding people up don't you attackmusic?

Nope, I just point out how ridiculous many posts in this thread are. If people get wound up by the truth that is their issue I just have a huge problem with the hypocrisy in this thread and people trying to decide what other peoples sexuality is. This thread is no different from the people who say bisexuality and homosexuality don't exist.

IMO Harold is bi (or he'd at least be open minded about dating any gender really) and his band mate is gay. I highly doubt Larry is actually real but I think they both would go for guys .

Tomas, I agree with you on Nathan...all the over the top denial... It seems a little too much.

You're insane. Talk about putting words in people's mouths. Would be funny if it wasn't so pathetic.

Dee, you're right. Attackmusic is the typical person who puts homophobic words in people's mouths which they never said. She is the homophobic one.

Insane? Either insane or a fan troll. My bet is on "fan troll"

(Sorry, Jenny. I couldn't help myself)

it is hard to resist sometimes! I don't understand why she and others like her come on here when they have such a problem with anyone suggested to be gay. News flash: lots of people are in the closet and have fake relationships to cover it up. It's true of people not in the public eye so it's not gonna be different in show biz. As I have always said, what should upset people is the fact that people have to do this.you are right, anyone who gets so angry when you say someone might be gay, like it is such a terrible thing, is clearly homophobic themselves.

Way to prove my point
Has no legitimate reason to think what I am saying is untrue so resorts to calling me homophobic. Typical, and actually offensive to the group you say you belong too.

Since when is pointing out the hypocrisy of refusing to believe someone is straight being homophobic? You clearly have issues judging by your "reasons" someone might be gay Jenny. I support equal rights for everyone and hate it when ANYONE is told they are something they are not. It is the same when insane Matt Bomer fangirls claim he is really straight or bisexual! How are you claims less ridiculous than theirs, especially considering the ratio of straight people to those of us in the LGBT community? Or are you going to say I am not really bisexual and show your hypocrisy again.

If someone says they are straight, says they are in love and in your mind you assume they could be lying, that is unfair and you know it. Not sure why I am trying to explain these things to people who are too delusional to see the truth. Let me guess you guys frequent the L chat and Datalounge and not ironically?

Agree, Jenny.
They're homophobic and hypocritical fans who like putting their words in other people's mouths, as dee rightly said. Pathetic and delusional.