The fact that it was unexpected is far from irrelevant. In fact, it is probably the most relevant of my points. The fact that it was unexpected helped ensure that no further criticism of the act occurred. And it succeeded nicely. How many people are now criticising the act in question and ignoring the comment?

He has apologised live on extra factor and there was also an explanation about a smoking/breath discussion he had with Tulisa before tonights show started

Borelow becomes Borelowblow.

Way too personal a remark to make on live television, and as usual delivered in such a humourless manner. Last year there was him and Rowland making fun of Louis' age, though she was the worst offender, and now this.

I didn't know Tulisa smoked!

or like err you stink if red wine. Yep really mature

Unfortunately Tulisa's response was even worse in that it was a copy of Gary's comment.

As they were on the subject of playground insults, the correct response would have been "your mum has fag ash breath".

How many people will feel compelled to vote for "the act in question" as a result of the comment?

If he wanted to stop criticism of "the act in question", he is about three weeks too late.

After his Fag Ash Breath comment Barlow = TV legend forever.

Greatest ever moment in the X-Factor, we've been building up 10 years for this.

He was better than jade.

He wasn't attempting to stop criticism made 3 weeks ago. He was trying to stop the steamrollering and inevitable bandwaggoning that would have happened tonight. Job done.

Would he have said the same to Cheryl and Simon I wonder

Totally Spot on!! I agree, If Gary Borelow's brains were made of cotton wool, he wouldnt have enough to make a tampax for a worm Shame Shame Shame on Our national Treasure

I agree with this. I actually quite like Tulisa and felt sorry for her when Gary came out with his outburst. It wasn't funny at all. It actually came out as being extremely hurtful. It showed Gary's nasty side.

As did I.

Gary is an evil bully and my children were in tears at his foul misogynistic behaviour. It’s a disgrace.

My partner and dog threw up at the comments and my Hamster is inconsolable I am Suing ITV for the cost of counselling. :|

Hilarious

I didn't find it funny tbh. There was no need for a personal dig. I find Gary less likeable each week.

When did this happen? I fast forwarded through most of the acts to see Rylan but didn't see this.

It was after Chris sang.

I chuckled hearing this last night.

It does make me wonder though if some of this is scripted.

I'm that cynical I think half the stuff on the show is scripted to get people talking about this awful show.

The top comment on the video




http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RW1Fhxa7-aQ

Ah the classic 'I can't argue with your logic so I'll just stick in a personal insult'. Nice one Borelow.

In this instance I have no sympathy for Tulisa - she clearly has it in for Chris as she did for Mischa B last year. She can dish is out but can't take it. Chris is a far better singer than Rylan yet he gets nothing but praise week in week out - Gary is the only judge that tells the truth - Rylan did take the place of one of the 3 boys sent home who were all better singers.

People who think that was a "quality putdown" or in any way hilarious SERIOUSLY need to get out more. It's the kind of thing I would have said in primary school. I think the audience's reaction said it all really, it was just very petty, immature and just plain pathetic. Gary is honestly such a ridiculous person.