(in my opinion, of course):
[LIST][*]The FUN factor.[/LIST]With this, I don't mean a complete and utter tripe performance from Rylan every week - who surprisingly manages to sing Gangnam Style and Horny out of tune? I don't find him entertaining in the slightest, but some of you might. I also don't mean the likes of Jedward or Wagner either. I mean someone who is naturally funny: Alexandra Burke was always quite hilarious; Rachel Adedeji falling over at Judges Houses; someone like Ray Quinn was someone I also found quite funny. However, these could all sing? I don't understand how the only category of "entertainment" on this show is a dire, dire performance a la Rylan? It makes no sense. The acts left barely have a personality between them.
[LIST][*]The BIG vocalist.[/LIST]The show HAD the big vocalist of Melanie before they decided to send her home over three boys who are just awful vocalists. The predictability from each of the acts left is becoming ridiculous. Ella will slightly above-average sing a song and will get overpraised to the heavens, but it's nothing she hasn't done before. Jahmene will oversing anything. Christopher doesn't know the difference between subtlety and belting. Apart from Jaymi in Union J, the other three and the rest of the acts are horrendous vocally.
I mean; I would much rather see this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXNGxPpxtEk#t=0h1m29s
than this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2xLznoymkuI#t=0h3m21s
Taking Melanie out of the show has really damaged the excitement for me, I was so excited to see what else she can do with her voice. I know she's not for some because she "shouts" or whatever
, but the acts left are just horrendous.
Yeah, I had like 10 minutes of doing nothing so I thought I might as well make a thread regarding my excellent thoughts.
[LIST][*]The FUN factor.[/LIST]With this, I don't mean a complete and utter tripe performance from Rylan every week - who surprisingly manages to sing Gangnam Style and Horny out of tune? I don't find him entertaining in the slightest, but some of you might. I also don't mean the likes of Jedward or Wagner either. I mean someone who is naturally funny: Alexandra Burke was always quite hilarious; Rachel Adedeji falling over at Judges Houses; someone like Ray Quinn was someone I also found quite funny. However, these could all sing? I don't understand how the only category of "entertainment" on this show is a dire, dire performance a la Rylan? It makes no sense. The acts left barely have a personality between them.
[LIST][*]The BIG vocalist.[/LIST]The show HAD the big vocalist of Melanie before they decided to send her home over three boys who are just awful vocalists. The predictability from each of the acts left is becoming ridiculous. Ella will slightly above-average sing a song and will get overpraised to the heavens, but it's nothing she hasn't done before. Jahmene will oversing anything. Christopher doesn't know the difference between subtlety and belting. Apart from Jaymi in Union J, the other three and the rest of the acts are horrendous vocally.
I mean; I would much rather see this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXNGxPpxtEk#t=0h1m29s
than this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2xLznoymkuI#t=0h3m21s
Taking Melanie out of the show has really damaged the excitement for me, I was so excited to see what else she can do with her voice. I know she's not for some because she "shouts" or whatever
, but the acts left are just horrendous.Yeah, I had like 10 minutes of doing nothing so I thought I might as well make a thread regarding my excellent thoughts.
