Ella's version v Caitlin's version which is closer to the original with added male backing.

Which do people prefer

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CC6vDsm1dXQ

V

Caitlin's is from The Voice last night

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IkIzjlgfODQ

I loved Caitlin so I think I'll say she did it better.. although I know Ella's voice is better and caitlin kinda ikitated amy lee, I still think she gave a more emotional rendition and this song needs one

I preferred Ella sorry even if was a completely different arrangement. That Caitlin girl sounded a bit too screechy for my liking.

I love that song so I preferred Caitlin's version which is a bit closer to the original. However Ella did try to make it her own version I guess.

Ella's was an off-key abomination of earrape, so Caitlin.