For me it has.

Rylan VS Carolynne - I wanted Carolynne to stay, always been a fan, her sing-off was great.
District 3 VS Melanie - I wasn't fussed but prefered Melanie.
MK1 VS Kye - Thought MK1 were so exciting.
Jade VS Union J - Thought Jade was phenomenal in the sing-off.

Never had this happen to me on a series before lol! But, I don't really have any favorites left now. So doubt it will happen again.

It's quite hard to care but I'd say the only one that I thought was really unjust was this week, Jade losing out to Union J.

Rylan v Carolynne - Easy, Carolynne should have stayed.
District3 v Melanie - Easy, Melanie should have stayed
MK1 v Kye - Wasn't particularly bothered at either outcome, if pushed, I'd rather MK1 had stayed
Union J v Jade - Biggest injustice this series, and I actually quite like Union J

We have not yet had a sing off decided on the performance in the sing off

Absolutely.

I wanted Carolynne to stay,
I wanted Melanie to stay,
I wanted MK1 to stay,
I wanted Jade to stay.

The trouble is that each year the judges say "we're looking for something completely different".
NO YOUR NOT.
You're just looking for another boy or girl band or singer that everyone under the age of 20 is sexually attracted to.

I don't know if anyone heard Louis say to Sharon at the judges house "the show has changed since you were on it". I thought no it hasn't.
You're still looking for the same boring type artists.

Rylan VS Carolynne - Carolynne deserved to stay but I wasn't that fussed.
District 3 VS Melanie - Melanie deserved to stay.
MK1 VS Kye - Not fussed but prefer MK1.
Jade VS Union J - I'm a massive fan of Union J so obviously I back the decision

Rylan v Carolynne: Right.
District3 v Melanie: Right.
MK1 v Kye: Wrong.
Union J v Jade: Wrong.

2/4 is fine, I feel satisfied with the results so far this year.

Sadly, yes.

REALLY??

Are you honestly saying that Rylan should have stayed over Carolynne. You're joking surely. You don't think that was unjust.
The fact that Rylan got through the audition stage is unjust.

Yup - Carolynne was only ok and Rylan was destined to provide much more entertainment value than many of them.

I'd rather see an amusing novelty act in the long run combined with more individual singers rather than an endless stream of mediocre pub singers who have nothing special to offer (and I mean the likes of Carolynne, Christopher, Kye for example.)

Rylan v Carolynne: Wrong, Carolynne was amazing
District3 v Melanie: 100% Wrong, Melanie should have stayed, She was one of my fav ever
MK1 v Kye: Wrong - Wasn't too fussed but MK1 were bearable
Union J v Jade: Right - Union J fan so

They were right to keep Rylan, and I wasn't too fussed either way this week. Wrong to get rid of Melanie and Mk1 (Over Kye at least)

Rylan vs Carolynne: Didn't care. Sort of glad Rylan stayed just because everyone got their knickers in a twist over it.

District 3 vs Melanie: Preferred Melanie

MK1 vs Kye: Hmm I didn't really like MK1 so I'm glad they left

UJ vs Jade: Liked Jade.

WK1 - I wanted Carolynne to Stay
WK2 - I wanted Melanie to Stay
WK3 - I wanted Kye to Stay
WK4 - I wanted Union J to Stay

so half and half at the moment; however I think Carolynne and Melanie completely outsung Rylan and D3 and really it was a joke how Louis voted and Tulisa voting to save D3 as they are vaguely urban?

Agree with this completely.

All wrong bar Week 1 imo, though the only one that really annoyed me was Jade going.

Week 1 - thought Carolynne was obviously the superior singer, while Rylan has done the same thing every week and got very predictable. Wrong result.

Week 2 - was more excited about Melanie's performances, even though District3 need the practice. So on a personal level - wrong result.

Week 3 - Kye has a strong voice, but MK1 are certainly more interesting and relevant for today's chart. Plus I don't really like Kye's personality anymore. Wrong result, though a close call.

Week 4 - WORST RESULT YET!!! Jade was my favourite with a great tone, and her sing-off performance showed how strong she is. Union J sounded awful and are incredibly boring, we have one boyband in the competition and 1D in the charts already, so don't really need them. Wrong result.

So 4 out of 4 wrong decisions.
This series was looking on shaky ground going into the live shows, so they are really pushing it with these sort of results.

I wanted Carolynne, Melanie, MK1 and Jade to stay, and they were all eliminated.

Wanted carolynne to stay...but of late Mr Rylan has proved to be 'entertaining'

Wanted Melanie to stay......not happy that weekend

Wanted Kye to stay......just for his song choice and sing off song too!!

Wanted Jade to stay......singoff song was the best she did during the LIVE shows!!

Rylan VS Carolynne
Rylan, although I'm sure is a nice guy, shouldn't last another week in the competition. He is a terrible singer and is just there to be the Jedward/Wagner of 2012.

District 3 VS Melanie
Although I liked Melanie, I'm a big fan of previous work District 3 have done and are much much better than they are showing on the show. Maybe their links to Capital owner Ashley Tabor will help their career more than the show will anyway.

MK1 VS Kye
Don't get Kye at all, haven't since his audition whereas MK1 were a fresh act for the group who they shouldn't have messed with.

Jade VS Union J
Dislike Union J immensley immensely anyway but Jade was absolutely flawless in the sing-off and they should have been gotten rid off. They aren't a harmonising boyband, they are four (if you count JJ) boys singing the same song at the same time.

I've agreed with 1 exit so far and until Rylan and Chris are eliminated, I'll probably continue to be disappointed with the exit.

week 1 - Carolyn sang it out of the ball park whereas Rylan was as expected; Karaoke. Wrong choice

Week 2 - Distrct3 were very poor where as Melanie was unique and powerful and stunning. Worst decision ever!

Week 3 - Not too fussed either way. But MK1 definitely improved that week whilst Kye was still barely memorable. So Wrong choice again.

Week 4 - Was starting to like Union J but that sing off was awful. They could not keep in synch were off the beat and it hurt my ears. Jade sang with passion and beautifully and I really felt like she wanted this. Wrong decision. (And Gary was talking gonads)

So I disagreed with every week. Only Week 3 would not have been too great a loss either way.

WK1 - Wanted Carolynne to stay
WK2 - Wanted Melanie to stay
WK3 - Wanted Kye to stay
WK4 - Wanted Jade to stay, terrible result IMO

I have agreed with and supported every outcome thus far.. sing-offs are utterly irrelevant; just ignore them and it all makes perfect sense.

Rylan VS Carolynne
District 3 VS Melanie
MK1 VS Kye :sleep:
Jade VS Union J

Rylan VS Carolynne- Wanted Rylan to stay (RIGHT)
District3 VS Melanie- Wanted Melanie to stay (WRONG)
MK1 VS Kye- Wanted MK1 to stay (WRONG)
Jade VS Union J- Wanted Union J to stay (RIGHT)
So it's been equal so far....