Originally Posted by elphaba7589:
“I see where you're coming from vf.
However I think Yasmin should have all 3 of her parents in her life. And by Amira turning up and demanding Yasmin go with her to Birmingham she is taking Yasmin away from the father's she knows and loves. In order to have regular contact with Yasmin they will have to uproot their entire lives to another part of the country just because Amira is marrying some man she barely knows, it's very unfair imo. No consultation with Chryed, just turns up and demands Yasmin comes with her.
And personally I think Chryed are way better parents because they capable of love and selflessness, two things which Amira isn't. All she cares about is herself, if she cared about Yasmin she wouldn't be taking her away from her settled, loving home.”
To be fair, Amira didn't turn up and demand that Yasmin go with her. She came to Syed about the fact that she's getting married, that they plan to settle in Birmingham and that they
want Yasmin to live with them. I didn't see anyone laying down the law, I saw someone broaching a very difficult issue as sensitively as she could, in the 20 seconds she was allowed.
Yes, Yasmin is happy and settled with Chryed, but up to the point that Amira went travelling (possibly just a month or so ago - Christian's postcard line, "First Paris, now Rome" suggests that the trip started with Paris, not that Amira had been gone for months on end), she would have been happy and settled with her mother. She has not forgotten Amira; yes, she'll be upset initially when she leaves Chryed but after a short period she'll be absolutely fine.
I don't see Amira's desire to have Yasmin move with her as selfish, or as evidence she doesn't care for her daughter, I just don't. Despite their history Amira tells Christian she wants/ hopes he will continue to play a role in Yasmin's life - if this isn't proof that she's grown and that actually she cares first and foremost about Yasmin, what is it? She has the chance to build a new life for them, to provide emotional and financial stability (not that Chryed can't, but this is about Amira as a mother) and of course she wants this, for her daughter and for herself. Having seen the scene tonight I don't think for a minute she's getting pleasure at the thought of separating Yasmin from Chryed, but her fiance's professional, financial, personal ties are elsewhere - this is the reality of the situation.
Re. the fiance: IMO at this late stage in the s/l the fact that Amira has become engaged quickly is neither here nor there. She's clearly happy, she's marrying him, that's it. From what I can remember we had a spoiler that the fiance actually appears on screen, so it sounds like he comes to collect Yasmin with Amira. I bet he's lovely, the ideal man. This isn't about Yasmin being wrenched from the arms of loving, decent parents and sentenced to a life of torment with people who don't have what it takes to love her or raise her well. This story is about Syed: fiance's going to be caring, charming, successful, keen to become the best stepfather he can to Yasmin, and it will just help to confirm in Syed's mind that he's made a mess of everything in his own life.