He says to Ella. That'll be Alexandra Burke so pissed off.com.

Alexandra who ?

Have we not done this at least 10 times already.

Tbh not even just Alexandra but Rebecca Laura White Ruth Lorenzo Amelia Lily and Misha B are all far superior to her imo.

Oh good another thread on this. He has a right to an opinion, I dont know why anybody would get so worked up about what Louis has to say anyway

Alexandra Burke. the best singer from X-Factor since Leona Lewis. Try and remember next time.

Hell no. Rebecca no also but she's not a hell no

Oh deary me, your actually being serious haha !

I don't know why there needs to be comparisons. Leona can sing, Alexandra can sing, Ella can sing. They can all sing very well.

EDIT - more than "very well", I should say. Leona's performances of 'I Will Always Love You', Alexandra's 'Listen' and then Ruth's 'Purple Rain' were all incredible vocal performances.

And I love Rebecca but the only thing going for her is her tone. Her voice is a bit thin and she can't really do low notes.

I agree, it's all about preference and I prefer Ella and Rebecca.

Im suprised he didnt say "you remind me of a young..........so and so".

But he only does that for black contestants.

Thats just what I thought. She has far more personality too.

People like comparisons.

The whole point of X Factor is to find the best act.

Wouldn't be much point to the show if they just said that everyone could sing and that was that.

Doubt it. she made her money, she won't be bothered. She'll know she has more vocal talent than Ella (although the girl can sing). Why be pressed (if you're the subject) about a lessor?

No girl on XFactor has ever come close to Leona.

this

Not true : he compared Lucy Spraggan to Victoria Wood and Kate Nash.

I agree with Louis.

Obviously you have a different idea of quality to me, but Alexandra Burke was more successful than most women singers on the show. I predict Ella won't be able to match that success. But we'll see.

Ella is good but that comment was not right.

Alexandra,Misha and Stacey Solomon are far better than her.

I agree with Louis too.

Everything and everyone is the best thing since 10 minutes ago with Louis. I think he may have Alzheimer's. One million "percent" yes!

[quote=gavin shipman;62303322]Ella is good but that comment was not right.

Alexandra,Misha and Stacey Solomon are far better than her.[/QUOT

dont make laugh .stacey soloman .ella in a different league

Nothing that Louis said should really be taken seriously. After all he was the one that didn't pick AB for the live shows, yet when she came back with a different mentor, she won the whole show.

I always thought the best vocal since leona was Lucy Jones myself.


Rebbecca is the best recording voice to ever appear on the show male or female though.