Is he?

Maybe in your eyes. I don't find him any of the above. In my eyes he can't sing, doesn't entertain me one iota, and has nothing interesting about him. Different opinions and all that

Massive YAY from me.

(I'm actually getting a bit obsessed if I'm honest, just been watching all his X Factor auditions and performances on Youtube. I'd forgotten about the Diva singoff at bootcamp, don't think I was a fan then though...)

Yay, but then I never disliked him.

ditto. He is the only one who looks as though he is enjoying himself.

Nay

I don't think he is entertaining at all

Yay at times
Nay at others

Actually out of all the camp, bizarre, entertainment rather than vocal acts that have come through the XF outing I like Rylan the most.

Not normally my bag but Rylan is quite likeable.

Hope this gets him something. I am sure it will.

Nay and Yay! I dont "enjoy" his performances as such because he really cant sing, but he does put on a good show and seems like a very well liked person backstage.

Personally I think so, but then I didn't like Wagner or find him remotely interesting or entertaining which seems to be a fairly unpopular opinion on here.

Wagner didn't do it for me either. The only time I laughed was when Louis repeatedly got his name wrong

yay, not because he can sing though, but because I love his enthusiasm and his sense of humour, the way he obviously gets on with everyone and never has a bad word to say, he seems like a really genuinely nice guy and I look forward to seeing what he's going to come out with every week. Admittedly at first I didn't like him at all, but he's grown on me as the weeks have gone on.

This is it! Rylan has entered into the silly spirit of the nonsense that is the X Factor whole heartedly. He is absolutely shining by being a part of it all. He doesn't think he's anything he's not. He's a believer in having fun and doing all he can to provide a good show. And I very much doubt he'll ever talk the show down long after it and the tour is over. Rylan won't backbite at the chances he's been given.

Massive yay! I love Rylan and have done since day one!!! xxx

Yay, baby Yay

yay - all the way.

Nice chap.

Yay, Rylan knows how to truly live in the moment and appreciate the chance he's been given. ooxx

Yay

[quote=maureens;62300094] *hands up* i will take my punishment with grace and dignity........................................... he is

Cannot sing, but neither can I! Pure entertainment, really funny and humble......Love him.


Cannot wait to see him on Chat shows, will be a scream......but Babes don't sing x


Yay Yay Yay

Really!! So nobody else is 'enjoying' the fact they are actually on X factor? What a strange thing to say.

Or could it be the rest don't prance and mince about and pretend to cry and love everybody?

I'm pretty sure each and everyone of them are 'enjoying' themselves. They're just not attention seeking, fame hungry wannabes.

Possibly not. But some harp on with the sob stories and that gets right on my wick to.

And mine.. It's had it's fair share of them this year.:yawn:

Nay
Too much mince for me

It doesn't make you an attention seeking, fame hungry wannabe to act in the way Rylan does. I'm sure they're all enjoying it and having the time of their life etc, but he's the only one that really shows it.

Pretending to cry? Have you not heard Nicole and the other contestants say that his reaction lasted for about an hour afterwards. He's a genuine, fun-loving guy and everybody who meets him says so, as if he keeps up for the bant, he's the most REAL on the show.

I'm sure he's a nice guy. But then I know lots of nice people who I wouldn't enjoy watching on the X Factor. He is a terrible singer and I don't get the entertainment value of him prancing around on stage in silly costumes.