He had an opinion, she shot him down and then tried to play the victim. Really went off her after that. He done himself justice by saying sorry but I wouldn't have.

Agree with hugo and eric she does talk down to people and shouts them down as well,i wouldve told her to shut up.

Agree,Rosemary is beginning to be a bit annoying with her prissyness.

Yep, she thinks her opinion is law and anyone who disagrees is being rude.

Rosemary is a passive aggressive and she showed herself tonight and was just that .She riled him , then played the victim .

I went off Rosemary tonight.

Shes a self opinionated fool, whos used to having her own way.. well good for Hugo for standing up to her.. she tried every ploy in the book to make him feel ashamed, and it should have been her who was ashamed...

She is very passive aggressive isn't she?

They guy did nothing wrong and she tried to make him look like the bad guy.

The argument can't have just happend because of the leaves chat. Clearly the director edited out other things Hugo has said to annoy her.

She did feel bad about it and tried to make up for it at dinner.

I am sure she won't react again, she is a jolly person who is in need of some Rumpy Pumpy.

Maybe there was sexual tension between her and Hugo.

She reminds me of my best friend, she can never be wrong! So annoying.

The Hayemaker must have pressed the wrong buttons .She went off like a rocket and couldnt stop yacking on

Agreed. She bossy with everyone but with Hugo she worse.
Always trying to make out his a rude spoilt child, I havent seen any evidence of this, only some moaning. When she was clearly whispering and he pointed it out she saud he was rude, when he gave his theory on the leaves she disagreed with it said he was wrong and was apparently rude, even when he apologised she kept going on and on.

I agree it was edited or they were told or egged on to do this. Rosemary has been calling Hugo spoilt and annoying since day 1 and we haven't really seen this to the degree that makes her this annoyed.

The arguement made her look ridiculous and I'm not defending her because I've never liked her and I do like Hugo but I don't believe she's lost her marbles. Clearly there was an agenda there and it was either Rosemary's clumsy attempt to get Hugo riled or the producer's clumsy attempt to make us hate her.

The producer's won but still it didn't look totally truthful.

It wasn't even an argument.

But Rosemary just had to keep going on and on... and on.

The question is, are the leaves smelly because they've had dirty water dry on them, or they're naturally smelly?

You have a best friend like Rosemary - just a thought get rid of your best friend

yep i agree people. rosemary was totally in the wrong there. she just completely went at hugo without good reason. i thought the points he was making were very valid and he handled it brilliantly. the thing which impressed me most about hugo is how he always always apologises for upsetting anyone.

I would love to see Rosemay boil her bloody head in oil. She is seriously getting on my nerves

Rosemary made a total bad show of herself. Tried to make herself look good by making Hugo look bad. That's always a dangerous ploy prone to backfiring.

I think Rosemary is trying to start to stir the pot, tried to make Hugo look bad, but it backfired.

i don't buy this at all. she was being herself.
i've often found her not just bossy as some have put it (the bossy while cooking i don't mind particularly) but she can be very overbearing, raising her voice and repeating statements over and over. it's a shame because outside of this she can be quite nice and funny. i really liked her at the start but as her armour has started to peel away i'm not always liking what i'm seeing.

Rosemary definitely did herself no favours last night but I think eric got it spot on that she was having a bad day.
Erics a grumpy old g!t
David's a wind-up merchant
Helen's a whiner
Hugo's spoilt
Rosemary's bossy
All of them have their personality traits. I still like Rosemary but she was pretty ungracious when Hugo was trying to apologise, that was the worst bit imo.

Please dont put 'rumpy pumpy' and Rosemary in the same sentence!