The X Factor USA – Live Show 5 - Wed Nov 28th, 8/7c FOX - Discussion Thread

9 of 9

susie-4964

01-12-2012

Originally Posted by LynxSoldier:
“I hated Vino's attitude though. He took every critique personally. And he wasn't exactly gracious in his defeat. A lot to dislike in my opinion, and he was a very bland and safe singer.”

I think he had a great soul voice, but he doesn't have the look, unfortunately.

I think Carly Rose is amazing, and I like Diamond as well. CeCe is a dreadful plastic doll who couldn't interpret a song if her life depended on it.

SULLA

03-12-2012

Originally Posted by EvilLlamaThingy:
“The performances are quite long tonight aren't they?”

It felt like they were being stretched out...Rather repetitive

Originally Posted by james2018:
“That girl's grandad might have moved them up the leaderboard a little, but they could still be in danger”

They should not broadcast such things at all...unfair

Originally Posted by beepbeep77:
“Why do Americans love people like Tate so much? he would have gone home first week in our version...”

This thread proves that we in the UK don't appreciate Country music

Originally Posted by Master Ozzy:
“I wouldn't count CeCe out of the game just yet. She's a fighter and the come back queen.”

I get the impression that she is now regarded as an underdog and is getting sympathy votes

Originally Posted by beepbeep77:
“Diamond doesnt seem the kind to burst out crying, she took her exit in the first week well, so she should be fine ”

She was crying even when LA predictably voted against her

My rankings

1. Carly
2. Diamond
3. Tate
4. Vino
5. Cece
6. Paige
7. Fifth Harmony
8. Emblem 2 plus Muscle Mary ( I had to laugh when he tore his shirt off

)

Flower Pot

05-12-2012

only just had time to watch the show & a few shockers in there! o.O

carly rose's performance.............shes 13, REALLY?! absolutely fantastic, will be a huge star

paige leaving before cece? who the hell is voting for her? shes dreadful!

simon voting for diamond to stay over vino. o.O thought he would have taken it to the vote but shes been consistently lower than vino so i'm guessing she was again & he didnt want her to leave. waste of time simon, shes a goner soon anyway.

tate & carly being within 1% of each other. wtf is wrong with the US voters, they wouldnt know vocal talent if it bit them in the ass!

9 of 9