• TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
  • Follow
    • Follow
    • facebook
    • twitter
    • google+
    • instagram
    • youtube
Hearst Corporation
  • TV
  • MOVIES
  • MUSIC
  • SHOWBIZ
  • SOAPS
  • GAMING
  • TECH
  • FORUMS
Forums
  • Register
  • Login
  • Forums
  • TV
  • The X Factor
Poor Steve what about poor Sharon
<<
<
3 of 3
>>
>
Popidolveteran
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by allinuse:
“PIV, I think you'll find you've strayed into uncharted waters

I too thought this was a thread debating El Diva, but *whispers* apparently it's another three wise monkeys zone.

(disclaimer smiley: that's hear no evil, see no evil, BTW, not a personal remark)”


Yes I hear Beth Hart will come on here anytime soon with a new dictat saying..."No-one must say anything other than charming platitudes about the towering musical talent aka as Stevo."
stillrockin
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by peacellily:
“well bloody said!!

I am not a fan neither to I dislike him but lets keep this in perspective, we dont know them!!!

We dont know what really went on now do we..............”

Do we care!!!! Steve will make it or not depending on what he does from now on - who cares about on and off air squabbles - what relevance do they bear to his ability to succeed in the long term?
Susann
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by stillrockin:
“I have to take exception to that. I'm a Tabby fan and am in no way bitter. I advocated from the beginning that Steve would win this show based on his singing style, demeanour and the voting pattern displayed in other reality talent competitions. My opinion is that winning is not particularly important in the long term scheme of things. He has the guarantee of a record deal and subsequent marketing but no guarantee of success. Success rests on what he produces from here on in the way of convincing original material. The competition was a showcase only and too much relevance has been placed on winning rather than asking "where is this act actually going". IMO of course.”

Stillrockin. I would never have included you in that I always considered you one of the better poster's on this forum, because you can see past most stuff, and make quite a few good points so not intended towards you at all which is why, I said some. I did look back through a few of the poster's older posts and MOST of the pro-Sharon and anti-Steve posts on this thread ARE from some Tabby fan's and some G4 fan's.
peacellily
18-12-2004
Susann unfortunately thats what makes the world go around..

What I should have said when I started a title for the thread was

"Poor Steve what about poor sharon.... Anyone who doesnt worship Steve please dont post as you will offened half of the people on here"
allinuse
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by stillrockin:
“I have to take exception to that. I'm a Tabby fan and am in no way bitter. I advocated from the beginning that Steve would win this show based on his singing style, demeanour and the voting pattern displayed in other reality talent competitions. My opinion is that winning is not particularly important in the long term scheme of things. He has the guarantee of a record deal and subsequent marketing but no guarantee of success. Success rests on what he produces from here on in the way of convincing original material. The competition was a showcase only and too much relevance has been placed on winning rather than asking "where is this act actually going". IMO of course.”

You really do manage to nail it don't you! Great post, I'm jealous (but not bitter )
Susann
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by peacellily:
“Susann unfortunately thats what makes the world go around..

What I should have said when I stsrted a title for the thread was

Poor Steve what about poor sharon.. Anyone who doesnt worship Steve please dont post as you will offene have of the people on here”


You can't ask someone not to post on a thread, even if it was a sarkily made request. No-one offends me, as I know I make my point and get my point across as well as I can, without resorting hopefully to some of the nastiness I have encountered on some of these threads.
stillrockin
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by Susann:
“Stillrockin. I would never have included you in that I always considered you one of the better poster's on this forum, because you can see past most stuff, and make quite a few good points so not intended towards you at all which is why, I said some. I did look back through a few of the poster's older posts and most of the posts are from Tabby fan's and some G4 fan's.”

Thanks for that Susann
peacellily
18-12-2004
I think he will make it, no one can doubt he cant sing however a lot will depend on management if they keep churning out the boreing covers then people will soon tire, lets see the original Steve, I think thats what Sharon was harping on about all the time, she never saw the real him!
baileybots
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by peacellily:
“I dont mean this to be a hate Steve thread I dont mind him not a massive fan but I guess hes o.k.

However what I am fed up with its always poor steve, sharons nuts gone mad with her outburst. blah blah.

Can we just step back a sec for all we know he was horrible to Shraon and Rowetta and her pa.....

OK so sharon was un proffessional with her out burst however if he acting like a little shit then serve him right!!!

She shouldnt have attacked him like that on t.v however its well documented in various papers that Steve didnt get on with quite a few people so do we really know whats been going on?

After all a few hours tv on a saturday night that doesnt give us the right to slate their persoanlities as we know nothing really do we....

All we know is what we have seen with our own eyes and read in the press.

Those threads who know his sisters cousins best friends wife dont really count so they!!

Rant over....
”

a tabby fan comming to the rescue of saint sharon of shagdom
peacellily
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by Susann:
“You can't ask someone not to post on a thread, even if it was a sarkily made request. No-one offends me, as I know I make my point and get my point across as well as I can, without resorting hopefully to some of the nastiness I have encountered on some of these threads.”

Well as long as they are line line with digi spy rules people can post much what they like, wether or not the love or hate Steve, none of us can do anything about that
stillrockin
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by allinuse:
“You really do manage to nail it don't you! Great post, I'm jealous (but not bitter )”

Hi allinuse - I do think this forum gets bogged down in inconsequentials sometimes but as I haven't been here long maybe that's the normal way of things. - I don't know as I have nothing with which to compare. Who were you supporting by the way?
allinuse
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by stillrockin:
“Hi allinuse - I do think this forum gets bogged down in inconsequentials sometimes but as I haven't been here long maybe that's the normal way of things. - I don't know as I have nothing with which to compare. Who were you supporting by the way? ”

Well I bestowed my favour on G4, with Tabby warming up in the wings. You have to support someone in a competition, as well as have a Dick Dastardly in the running (Steve in my case for the record)

The board is pretty quiet now, but with some potentially good debates about the format, what happened etc. So I reckon past allegiances are irrelevant.

But I'm hampered by a G4 brand apparently... Hopefully more grown-ups will be out later.

Glad to see you still around - have you tried any of the other DS areas?
peacellily
18-12-2004
Hopefully more grown-ups will be out later.


well I am 35 do I quailfy
allinuse
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by peacellily:
“Hopefully more grown-ups will be out later.


well I am 35 do I quailfy ”


Absolutely
stillrockin
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by allinuse:
“Well I bestowed my favour on G4, with Tabby warming up in the wings. You have to support someone in a competition, as well as have a Dick Dastardly in the running (Steve in my case for the record)

The board is pretty quiet now, but with some potentially good debates about the format, what happened etc. So I reckon past allegiances are irrelevant.

But I'm hampered by a G4 brand apparently... Hopefully more grown-ups will be out later.

Glad to see you still around - have you tried any of the other DS areas?”

No. I haven't been anywhere else.

I probably wouldn't be here if I hadn't spotted Tabby on the first show and decided to find out a bit more background about him, which subsequently led me here.

I haven't any animosity against anyone supporting other acts. I can't understand all this personal affrontery as if you were attacking a family member - seems disproportionate to the subject - but that's just me I suppose.

I'll be interested to see how things unfold over the next few months though and whether I have been barking up the wrong tree
annabelle
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by stillrockin:
“No. I haven't been anywhere else.

I probably wouldn't be here if I hadn't spotted Tabby on the first show and decided to find out a bit more background about him, which subsequently led me here.

I haven't any animosity against anyone supporting other acts. I can't understand all this personal affrontery as if you were attacking a family member - seems disproportionate to the subject - but that's just me I suppose.

I'll be interested to see how things unfold over the next few months though and whether I have been barking up the wrong tree ”

Most of us on here don't feel any animosity towards anyone supporting other acts.You'll notice that most of the members of Team steve are on good terms with the G4 team and we have posted supporting messages on each others threads.
I dislike intensely tha anti threads most of which have been against Steve but in the past some were against G4.

I don't think any of us know how successful any of them will become.
I initially got taken with Tabby as my leanings are much more towards the rock genre. Steve is the first person who I've voted for who is not a rock singer.My liking for his voice has surprised me.
For Steve a door has opened for him and so it has for G4 and Tabby and hopefully Rowetta.What they make of it remains to be seen.It is an opportunity they would not have had otherwise ,nothing more.
Hopefully they will all achieve success in their different ways.
peacellily
18-12-2004
Originally Posted by allinuse:
“Well I bestowed my favour on G4, with Tabby warming up in the wings. You have to support someone in a competition, as well as have a Dick Dastardly in the running (Steve in my case for the record)

The board is pretty quiet now, but with some potentially good debates about the format, what happened etc. So I reckon past allegiances are irrelevant.

But I'm hampered by a G4 brand apparently... Hopefully more grown-ups will be out later.

Glad to see you still around - have you tried any of the other DS areas?”

mm thats what you get if you sway, hampered by the brand!!!! You will be struck down you know (lol).

I guess if I had to pick a favourite voice it would be rowetta although personality I would have to pick Tabby that kid on stage was very confident looked like a star, although I suppose he was used to an audience.
<<
<
3 of 3
>>
>
VIEW DESKTOP SITE TOP

JOIN US HERE

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Hearst Corporation

Hearst Corporation

DIGITAL SPY, PART OF THE HEARST UK ENTERTAINMENT NETWORK

© 2015 Hearst Magazines UK is the trading name of the National Magazine Company Ltd, 72 Broadwick Street, London, W1F 9EP. Registered in England 112955. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Complaints
  • Site Map