All the best Naruto

Good luck bboy. Come on Jake!

Gutted for the boys tonight especially as they won the sing off hands down, but well done to Jake.

Damn, I have to deal with Jake for another week

Thanks to everyone that voted Jake! And comisserations to The Risk and Bboy.

Ooooh, difficult theme......

Does the song have to be released in December? A lot of Xmas songs come out in November.

I always miss this thread sad to see The Risk go

So was I, I struggled to find a good song so went safe with the blue song and thought they wud be middle of the road and get through. But I honestly thought they were far better in the sing off and would be curious to see if EoS was actually online what way he would have voted. Would he have saved The Risk or stuck to his earlier vote.

Yea I didnt think they were the worst tonight.. now that I've catched up.
Loved Elesha, District3 and Belle Amie tonight..
And I personally think the tone criticism can be too over used at times.. it doesn't always mean that, for example James Arthur does a song by Adele, he must have the same tone as her. Just saying :sleep:

I'm glad to see Despina got through, I was actually very worried for her (hence me checking this thread at this time of the day ). Thanks to everyone who voted for her.

As for the two posts above me: Stephen, I think I would've taken it to deadlock either way as it seemed like the fairest decision, as I quite liked both sing-off songs. Not just The Risk's, although I must admit that it was pretty good and definitely made me think if tonight;s result was the right one.

Kuda, I think that the James example you used greatly exaggerates the whole thing. If someone were to give James an actual Adele song, and provided a link to the original version, I would give the tone criticism and call it unimaginative. However, if said mentor provided a link to a suitable cover, I might really like it and praise the performance. In other words, the tone criticism is used in situations where it's hard to imagine the act singing the song in the version provided. This doesn't just happen in these games too, there are very few artists who can deliver a Janis Joplin song for that matter.

Also, November isn't technically part of the winter Soppyfan, the season starts on December 21st.

So to clarify about the theme, any song released either in November or December can be used? And it doesn't technically have to be about winter?

You'll get my song choice by tonight, don't worry. To be honest I haven't even started looking...

Crap I thought we had untill tomorrow night to get songs didn't realise it was the show tomorrow night. I have only chosen 1 song so far but I will try to get the other 2 sorted now

sent my songs in a few minutes ago, so please take it easy on my acts tomorrow night and give them a chance