I have read many people say here how great looking she was not to mention the whole thing about her looks on the show itself.

But when they did close up's she was nothing amazing certainty not the kind of girl who would haver you giving a double take at if she passed you on the street.

Is her looks more emphasized by the fact she is a genuinely nice girl so that comes out.

Yes but she's living the jungle all day with no makeup, a tiny mirror and bad food! I think she's a natural beauty, and I don't think she actually needs to wear makeup. I don't think her beauty is overrated at all. Of course her personality factors into that but she's a nice-lookin girl with a great sense of humour I thought.

Also sorry to be annoying but it's *are* her looks overrated not is...

I think her looks are overrated. Next to Nicole she would look ordinary.

She's naturally very pretty for sure. I certainly wouldn't mind looking like her, hard to look that pretty in a hot sweaty jungle with no access to make up and stuff. Sadly I would look more like Rosemary.
Charlie is very pretty too.

Certainly not! She's has a quirky beauty in a Cameron Diaz way.

I have no idea who Nicole is or what she looks like so couldn't compare.

You are quite right I corrected it

TBH I was trying to type quick as my kitten was trying to pull the tree over

Contrare! Ashley is far cuter.

I'm not saying she doesn't have a better personality but looks wise, not in the same class.

Ashley's personality makes her more desirable than say Helen and I think she's more physically attractive too. Her athletic dancer figure is amazing, her proportions are spot on, she has flawless skin - unlike Helen, a beautiful smile that lights up her face...I could go on. I think her voice is a bit nasal so I suspect she may have had a nose job but other than that I think she's one of the most attractive women I've seen for a long time. Both inside and outside.

Another Pussycat doll and X-factpor judge. I refuse to spell her surname.

Have you got a link to a picture of her with no make up on otherwise it's impossible to say? I'd google but no has said who Nicole is or what her surname is.

Pfft I'm so old, I've heard of the pussycat dolls but have no idea about the members and I've never seen X factor. I'm intrigued as to what she looks like though!

Sorry, I can't do links, try google

I don't believe you do have never heard of The Pussycat Dolls

I prefer Ashley's looks but everyone has different opinions on looks, tis true.

I have heard of the pussycat dolls, I just don't know who is in the band or what they look like. I can even sing a bit of their song!

I dont agree. In fact, I think the opposite is true.

She looks very like Reece Witherspoon, I think.

I must say, to me she doesn't seem ar gorgeous-looking as many seem to find her, but she is without doubt an attractive girl and a lovely person.

The more you got to see of her and her personality the more attractive she got.

And that's what counts.

Yeah but i bet Nicole doesn't look good without any make up on.

Something weird going on with her jaws but it doesn't detract from her looks - she's appealing in a very wholesome, natural way. The killer toned dancer's bod doesn't hurt either

From roughly a year ago, but this should give some idea for comparing the two:

Nicole Scherzinger

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz...ust-towel.html

Ashley Roberts:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/t...10-review.html

(I've tried to get them at as similar an angle as possible, for a fair comparisson.)

I think her looks are underrated

Beautiful colour skin, pretty features and a lovely figure.

I agree but the OP was talking about her looks.

A better picture

http://www.gigwise.com/photos/78009/...e-as-a-popstar