District 3

Guys I am sorry to be the nasty judge but for your mentor to give you a song to sing when you have already covered it and there is a clip on youtube is another huge no no. Up to this point guys you have been doing well but after that I am fearful of you place as it would seem your mentor hasn't put much effort into your performance.

District3

I agree with Stephen, you really shouldn't have been given a song you have already covered. The vocals were great, but I am very disappointed in your mentor.

District3

That was a pretty good performance guys, at least good enough to secure yourselves a place in the fifth live show. However, I'd like you to sing something else than acoustic covers of popular pop songs sometime, as what you're doing now isn't exactly spectacular.

Elesha

Well well well Elesha, I can finally put my nasty side away and just say that was a great song choice from your mentor tonight. I thought when I first saw the song that it wouldn't have worked very well but I am glad to say I was wrong. It was delightful and got me in the Christmas spirit.

Elesha Moses

Elesha, that was exquisite! You had a lot of praise last week, and I hope that happens again this week. Great vocal performance.

Elesha Moses

That note was hilarious by the way, but that's not what I wanted to say. That was another good choice from your mentor there. This is the second Christmas song your mentor has picked tonight, and it was so much better than the last one as it kept your style intact and allowed you to use your phenomenal vocals. Ignoring Tim McGraw was difficult at times, but aside from that this was a good performance!

Carolynne

Carolynne I am so glad you have finally went back to your country roots again as this is definitely your unique selling point. It wasn't my favorite performance of yours but it was still a good performance tonight which I hope will see you through to the next show.

Carolynne Poole

Carolynne, I've always wanted you to sing a country song! That was a great choice from your mentor, the vocals were great.

Carolynne Poole

It seems that Carrie Underwood is used for you in every single game you're in. Maybe because she's a decent choice of artist for you. However, I have one big problem with this performance - because you performed a country song it felt very summery to me, while the theme is winter songs... Aside from that, decent performance. Well done!

Jade

Jade I so wish I had the time to pick a proper song for you. Although with the late late song choice aside it was still an absolute magical performance tonight. Your voice has the potential to move people emotionally and that's exactly what it has done tonight. I hope people will continue to support you so I can have a proper think about the next theme and get a really good song choice for you.

Jade Richards

Jade, I hate to say this, but I wasn't impressed by this. The vocals were a bit disappointing. The cover version was practically identical to the original Little Mix version.

On a short break so have time to respond to some comments.

Leanne's song choice was not a rule break. It was released digitally and physically in December in Americaso please do not take that into account when voting.

Also, how am i supposed to know all of the covers District3 have done as GMD3? What should matter is the performance in terms of vocals and arrangement. I did not know these boys have covered that song before and it would be impossible for me to keep track of them all.

Jade Richards

I believe I said this last week Jade, but I'm still waiting for you to embrace your husky vocal more. Also, I could clearly hear a backing track during the performance, while I know you can easily sing without one. One final thing, it could also be argued that this is in fact a rule breaker. Cannonball was released in either May or October (Ireland/UK), which clearly violates the rules. A counterargument would be that Little Mix's version was released in December, but that's technically a cover version so the release date should be invalid. I don't know what Soppyfan thinks about this, just thought I'd mention it.

You're right about this, the other judges are pulling all stops to make sure their acts will be safe tonight. It's perfectly normal though, I've seen it happen so many times on other games as well. :yawn:

Jake

Jake, that was a very samey performance as to when you sang on the real show at bootcamp. This didn't wow me in any way shape or form. You were saved by the public last time but after tonight I am extremely fearful as I don't think you are at the same standard as the others

Jake

*Yawn* Jake, it's no secret I'm not a fan of you, but that was just painfully boring. Vocals were same old same old.

Jake Quickenden

You've been in the sing-off twice in a row now, and I don't think your mentor has figured what the reason for that might be. I personally think the reason is the fact that you're constantly singing very samey songs. If you're safe tonight, I want your mentor to shake things up and bring out the unpredictable for you, as you DO have the potential to go far if you're given the right songs. Oh, and being the rule breaker police today, this song was released in September according to wikipedia. The album it was on was released in August, so that's no excuse either...

iv'e been watching Endofsanity you're so harsh.... i'm gonna vote too