Lets crank up the volume
Who would win in a sing off Cheryl, Tulisa or Dani
1 of 2
Dannii would win. I saw some clip of her singing on a theatre stage live and she was really great, I can't remember where it was. Cheryl, even though she mimes, has a decent studio voice and a better tone. She just sucks at live singing however can sound good with the right song, but even she would beat Tulisa, who is just dreadful...
She only sings in one strained shouty tone all the time it's painful to hear. She had to mime her head voice notes in Sight Of You on X Factor because she just has no range, and she always sings flat. She would lose. She works far better when she is just standing in the back of N-Dubz doing the background vocals.
She only sings in one strained shouty tone all the time it's painful to hear. She had to mime her head voice notes in Sight Of You on X Factor because she just has no range, and she always sings flat. She would lose. She works far better when she is just standing in the back of N-Dubz doing the background vocals.
Originally Posted by Zack06:
“Dannii would win. I saw some clip of her singing on a theatre stage live and she was really great, I can't remember where it was. Cheryl, even though she mimes, has a decent studio voice and a better tone. She just sucks at live singing however can sound good with the right song, but even she would beat Tulisa, who is just dreadful...
She only sings in one strained shouty tone all the time it's painful to hear. She had to mime her head voice notes in Sight Of You on X Factor because she just has no range, and she always sings flat. She would lose. She works far better when she is just standing in the back of N-Dubz doing the background vocals.”
“Dannii would win. I saw some clip of her singing on a theatre stage live and she was really great, I can't remember where it was. Cheryl, even though she mimes, has a decent studio voice and a better tone. She just sucks at live singing however can sound good with the right song, but even she would beat Tulisa, who is just dreadful...
She only sings in one strained shouty tone all the time it's painful to hear. She had to mime her head voice notes in Sight Of You on X Factor because she just has no range, and she always sings flat. She would lose. She works far better when she is just standing in the back of N-Dubz doing the background vocals.”
Basically what I was about to post.
Dannii wins fairly easily (definitely technically better, I think in some records her tone is annoying though so occassionally Cheryl beats her, but overall Dannii is best)
Cheryl sounds decent stood still, has a good pop voice for recording the pop music she does.
Tulisa sounds strained, even recorded. Flat, lifeless tone, forgettable material.
Originally Posted by teenage-monkey:
“http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SCdhr9jOTPM&t=4m18s
Dannii would win.”
“http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SCdhr9jOTPM&t=4m18s
Dannii would win.”
Not with that - AWFUL!
I would say Dannii first, then Cheryl who can sound good on the right songs ie A Million Lights Live, followed by Tulisa who I put in last place because she always sounds strained and like she is forcing her voice, which I really don't like.
Tulisa is probably the best singer naturally, even if her voice is a bit ugly on some songs. Dannii I love and her music is the best of the three (Neon Nights <3) but she isn't exactly a great vocalist. Cheryl is the worst of the three but has the braindead vote.
I think Dannii would looking at some videos of her singing live on youtube. Then maybe Tulisa. Cheryl wouldn't stand a chance.
Originally Posted by tellywatcher73:
“I wouldn't want to listen to them, one after the other, to find out!”
“I wouldn't want to listen to them, one after the other, to find out!”
it would be a hard slog. On the whole it's healthier just to argue it out
Dani, Cheryl is a very poor singer on her own, she should have stuck to being in a group, or doing backing vocals. Dani then Tulisa, then Cheryl
1 of 2
