What the title says....

Personally I'd think/love Leona Lewis and Mel B! I actually wouldn't be surprised if Mel B replaced Tulisa on next year's panel. Nicole meanwhile MUST stay, she's been the life and soul of this year's XF panel!

i agree. nicole SHOULD stay!!

Mel B for sure. I liked Rita Ora too.

Katy Perry was pretty good last year too

^^^
Katy Perry - brilliant shout

I don't know whose more mental Nicole or Katy

I would love to see Simon return to

So maybe Gary, Nicole, Katy, Simon

I liked mel b and rita ora

Mel B.

i think MEL B!

Katy Perry was already offered a full time judging roll on X Factor, and to quote her quote in the papers she said, you have to be really careful about being a judge on these types of shows, if you make unpopular choices it can have a knock on effect on your own career, so no I would not do it full time.

Pretty smart if you ask me(edited to add this bit)

Anastacia for me. Really loved her as a judge.
Loved how honest Mel B was. She'd make a brilliant judge.

Katy Perry was great but she'd never do it full time. She's way too popular and busy.

I want Mel B to stay on the XF Australia as she makes the judging panel so much more interesting.

Leona Lewis was okay but she'd be a bit dull full time.

I think a Nicole and Rita Ora panel would work really well. They seem as though they'd get on and they're around the same age. Rita could add some sensible to balance out Nicole's crazy.

Rita Ora would do really well alongside Nicole.

Geri Halliwell for deffo. Also rather liked Rita Ora & Katy Perry.

Anastacia for me. She had the best reviews but we never got to see much of her. She admitted she had been offered the full time role but turned it down because she was doing Night Of The Proms Tour.

Didnt like Mel B at all, loved Rita Ora and can see her with Nicole

Loved Mel B, if Tulisa leaves, she should replace her.

mel b

Anastacia would be a good bet for next year if Cheryl returns and makes sure Nicole gets kicked off the panel. She just probably wasn't shown because she only did one day and noone notable auditioned.

Mel B.

If rumours are true, she was offered the job and then rejected in favour of Nicole. She hosts DWTS in Australia just before it starts so would maybe miss some auditions, and would also have to give up her role on X Factor AUS. All down to logistics I guess.

Pixie Lott and Leona for me. I think I could rely on them to make good decisions in the sing-offs.

Pixie Lott was bullied by Louis into a reverse decision regarding some no-hoper, Leona is a bit too nice, Mel B was a bit too panto baddie (and then when she was nice sounded disingenuous), Geri was mental in a bad way. Can't think of anyone else?

Hmm, you're looking for someone who will stand up for herself against Louis, someone not too nice and not mental...

I can think of one person, but this person was suddenly universally hated after her guest judging...okay.com?

I really liked Alexandra as a guest judge, I would have been more than happy with her as a regular judge.

It would be nice to have an X-Factor winner as a permanent judge.

How about Leon Jackson or Steve Brookstein - they have plenty of time on their hands these days!

Anastacia would be a great judge!

Genghis Khan

Vlad the Impaler

Ivan the Terrible

Stalin

That would sort them out!