Which guest judge(s) do you think could return to a full-time role?

2 of 2

Zack06

07-12-2012

Originally Posted by Satanel:
“Hmm, you're looking for someone who will stand up for herself against Louis, someone not too nice and not mental...

I can think of one person, but this person was suddenly universally hated after her guest judging...okay.com? ”

OK.com was the highlight of last series, people talk about 'her' and that phrase more than they do about most of the ex-contestants from that series....

jackbell

07-12-2012

Career killing.

Erica Cartman

07-12-2012

Mel B.

AJmaestro

07-12-2012

Originally Posted by Zack06:
“OK.com was the highlight of last series, people talk about 'her' and that phrase more than they do about most of the ex-contestants from that series....”

Who are you referring to?

Yeah_Jackie

07-12-2012

Alexandra Burke

Michelle_Clarke

07-12-2012

Originally Posted by burbe:
“What the title says....

Personally I'd think/love Leona Lewis and Mel B! I actually wouldn't be surprised if Mel B replaced Tulisa on next year's panel. Nicole meanwhile MUST stay, she's been the life and soul of this year's XF panel!”

Nicole needs to stay. 100% Tulisa needs to go she has looked bored and I am bored by her she only seems to sit on the sofa telling her acts to "do their own thing" which comes over as she cannot be bothered. I really hope she is not back next year. I would like Geri or MelB to replace her.

AJmaestro

07-12-2012

Oh stop! I really like Alexandra's music but as a judge she was terrible. I just wanted her to shut up! She seemed a bit over excited about everything she said!

Bjkaave

08-12-2012

Please take Mel B, she was a complete and utter c t on the Australian series this year, I would be glad to see the back of her!

trinity28

08-12-2012

Mel b

Seanie(:

08-12-2012

Ideal panel would be:

- Simon
- Nicole
- Mel B/Cheryl
- Louis

2 of 2