How about you guys?

Me too.

I prefer Beyonce's.

I preferred Carly's personally. The best version of If I Were a Boy I've ever heard on a reality TV competition is this one though.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kv71seG0n4E

I liked Rachel Crowe's.

I like Little Mix's version but Carly Rose's version was the best I have heard it!

I also preferred Dinah's version. I think that's probably because If I were a Boy is just one of those songs that needs a black female with strong vocals to reach it's full potential.

Err, Dinah I think is Tongan or something south pacific not black.

Same. I preferred Dinah's and Rachel Crow's rendition

Rachel's was my favorite. More emotional.

Oops. My bad. I wasn't entirely sure of her ethnicity.

The point still stands though as she has the same type of vocals as a lot of black females. That's why I feel the song suited her better.