This week i think:

Undermarked:

Denise

Overmarked:

lisa (obviously)
kimberley (a bit though it was very good)

Kim was overmarked for me as she messed up but I still liked it

The rest I agree with the scores

Overmarked

Kimberley - Probably worth 36 at most for me.

Lisa - Worth about 20

Nicky - I really didn't like his dance.

Undermarked -
on one everyone apart from Nicky a bit overmarked

way overmarked Lisa
Worst Dance of the night for me and was last week as well

I think most were overmarked to be honest, except Nicky and possibly Denise, but the order was about right (although personally I would switch Lisa and Nicky, and Denise and Louis.)

Lisa was severely over marked, she was dreadful!! I would have given her a 6 at the most...

Overmarked
Nicky
Louis

Overmarked? Lisa Lisa Lisa Lisa Lisa and bloody Lisa. No way was her effort better than Nicky's.

Nonsense You know nothing about the purity of Dance!

Overmarked:
Kimberley,
and has been since week one, in my opinion: Lisa.

Undermarked:
Nicky.

Thought Louis was overmarked tbh. The Rumba section was good, but the Tango was a bit frenetic and scrappy. Really enjoyed Kimberley's dance, not sure it quite merited a 40 but good on her.

Everyone else was about right, except for Lisa obviously, but that goes without saying by now.

Forget marks...think ot the order...right except for me Louis was so much better technically than Dani I would have had him second by 1 mark over her

Overmarked
Lisa and Robin
Louis and Flavia

Undermarked
Nicky and Karen

i thought that generally everyone was overmarked but it seems that that the marking scale increases as it get to the final irrespective of the actual level.

Overmarked
Denise - Lisa was better IMO. her and Lisa should have been switched on leaderboard IMO.
Nicky (I thought it was awful and even though he was bottom I thought it was still overmarked))

Everyone else I thought was marked fairly.

As I said on another thread once they had overmarked Lisa by so much there really wasn't much else they could do for a far superior version of the same combination.

If Kimberely deserverd a 36 then Lisa deserved a 20 (a 16 point difference which lead to Kim getting full marks).

Lisa - over
Nicky - under

I'm not particularly a Nicky fan but I felt quite sorry for him. AND how could Craig say he would be in the bottom 2 without seeing all the dances first?

I agree but would have been happy had they been equal second. Not sure Kimberley was worth the magic 40 but totally happy with her ranking.

Lisa - absolutely nothing positive to say about the judges comments and marks. I give up. But I don't like Nicky's dancing very much so I find it difficult to decision who I want at the bottom - maybe equal.

Lisa better than Denise, are you being serious ?

The fact that they are close on the leaderboard kind of puts the preconceptions implicit in the marking into context.

I agree, not a fan of Nicky either but the combination he got was the hardest by far and he was still much better than Lisa but somehow ended up with less marks!?!

Quite; that didn't make sense.

Denise - about right (and in response to a post above, no way was Lisa better than her - Lisa was better than no-one! )
Lisa - badly overmarked
Nicky - slightly overmarked
Dani - about right
Louis - overmarked
Kimberley - slightly overmarked (it wasn't perfect, but it should have scored about the same as Dani)

Oops sorry just realised that you were agreeing with me.

SORRY

In my defense the dog just threw up so I've been a bit distracted.

Don`t care much for Nicky but did feel sorry for him having the hardest fusion and iirc he hasn`t done any of the routines before unlike most of them.