Correctly said. Agree entirely.

Arent Tulisa and Cheryl friends though? and shes not likely to like Nicole after US Xfactor so its more likely to be Nicole who will go out of the two of them IMO

but that might just be the point... XF thrives on controversy

God, I so agree. I really don't understand all the fuss about her on X Factor. She was useless IMO. Bland cliched comments, very unintelligent. "You're reet up ma street", "Ah thoroughly enjoyed that", etc etc.

And I hated her 'chemistry' with Cowell, who made no attempt to disguise his favouritism towards her despite Danni being the viewers' favourite.

I think people are equating X Factor in its heyday with Cole's presence on the show. People being interested in her and the show, is not the same as her actually being any good.

If the vibrant, quirky, infinitely smarter Nicole gets bumped for Cheryl it'll be a travesty. Better to bump Tulisa, who's been something of a joyless wonder this season, who squandered arguably the strongest category (while Nicole had, for many of us, the weakest going in) and whose career is now flopping so badly she has no credibility.

I can also see Nicole singing that song to her. Thing is, we all know now that Nicole is incredibly eccentric and bubbly, whereas Cheryl is a moaning stiff, so she was bound to view Nicole's singing her song as an act of either competitiveness or 'weirdness'.

As for no star quality... strange thing to say. There's no disputing Cole has the 'X Factor', even before her million dollar make-over she was the one in Girls Aloud who stood out but I doubt she'd be considered 'all that' if she wasn't ridiculously attractive and the press hadn't hyped her incessantly for years, shoving her stardom down our throats.

Consider Nicole Schwarzinger who gets far less press but walks out on that stage and OOZES charisma. She knows how to work the crowd whereas Cheryl seems to think smiling enigmatically is all she needs to do (admittedly she has a gorgeous smile). That 'Angel of the North East' art work really is an apt description of her appeal. Nicole is also routinely funny and sassy with her judging comments, while Cheryl has a stock 10 cliches up her sleeve and very little else to say because I honestly don't think she's got the smarts to say more.

I don't want Cheryl back. Nicole >>>>>her.

Denied
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz...-shake-up.html

Nicole and Cheryl on the same panel.... Nicole would bring voodoo dolls on set

oh what i suprise simon trying to generate more pulicity to save the sinking show lets use the cheryl story again

... and that was after June 2009!

And how could he do that when Louis and the others said on the Xtra Factor that they don't know who will be chosen to judge until March. A load of nonsense I should think and why would we want Cheryl back anyway.

Well considering the show finished yesterday That makes no sense as it will already be all over the press with the winner etc... it`s the press that need to let go of this story and deal that Cheryl is a part of the past!

Agreed, and for Nicole to come back, Cheryl must definitely NOT come back. Cheryl was shockingly bad. She was boring, she was eye candy for me but she was just dull. Her comments would have made no profound difference to the series. Also she's a dick to Nicole and really full of herself. Nicole can actually sing and is the nicest person I've seen so far on the stage (she was so nice to Maloney even though she hated his guts).

Please Simon! Don't bring her back...

Oh well that's another reason why I won't be watching next year.

Back on the show?

She will be back deffo. What's betting the series gets the higgest ratings of all seasons now she is back

It would be like the UK suddenly getting an unknown (in this country) country singer like Lee Ann Womack or Sara Evans.

Would that really inspire people to watch?

X Factor USA has been a flop from start to finish- there is simply no room for it in the American market. It's one of the few countries with an Idol series, and it's Voice franchise is improving in ratings year on year.

Cowell tried to bring a singing show to a market that is already saturated with them.

I still have a huge feeling that she will definitely return. Kelly, Demi & Cheryl + Simon for Season 3

I think if Cheryl does come back then I think Demi should go or Cheryl should be on the UK version as they both feel the role of arguing and bantering with Simon so I don't think it would work.

Demi's return is official.

Demi can hold her own on panel regardless of where she's sitting....
but she's too young for the more flirty/playful banter that Cheryl pulls off with Simon.

Depends on who person #4 is, but if Cheryl is coming back to US X Factor, she's definitely sitting next to Simon.

Why? Not as if she is that big a name in the USA.

Unless the do a Cheryl on her and fire her.

The last thing the show could use is even more bad publicity

She wasn't fired. Simon explained on bbc r1 that she was transfered,that he did speak to her.
Cheryl is sticking to the axe story still.