[occy]

Please support this for Hillsbrough and make it become Christmas Number One.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2h8loYnNlZA

[lovelife7292]

it's ok but it's nothing new

[Mr Jazzman]

What a load of shite

[LandslideBrad]

I would actually rather donate money straight to the charity than buy that awful song.

[LFCKEV71]

Originally Posted by LandslideBrad

I would actually rather donate money straight to the charity than buy that awful song.

buy it then bin it

[jackbell]

Originally Posted by occy

Please support this for Hillsbrough and make it become Christmas Number One.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2h8loYnNlZA

Um, why?

[Kanzi]

It's a pretty crap cover let's be honest. When are they finally going to put McCartney to bed?

I'll donate directly.

[jackbell]

Originally Posted by LFCKEV71

buy it then bin it

Just donate a few quid then you won't even have to bin it and you'll stop encouraging self indulgent old pop stars to be seen to doing something for 'charadee'.

[Mr Jazzman]

Beverley Knight must be sat by the phone waiting for shit like this every few years

[1992]

#1 in the Official Chart Update

http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio1/chart/update/singles

The link will update soon.

[kvn]

Originally Posted by Mr Jazzman

Beverley Knight must be sat by the phone waiting for shit like this every few years

Beverley Knight's been a supporter of the Justice campaign for a few years actually not sure why you've singled her out

[Paul Wilson]

Awful version of an awful song. Bloody good cause though.

[soundstory]

I can't believe some of the comments here.

perhaps people should actually read what it's for first.....

[misslibertine]

Originally Posted by soundstory

I can't believe some of the comments here.

perhaps people should actually read what it's for first.....

I would imagine most people know what its for. You don't have to love the song just because its for charity.

I fully support the Hillsborough fight for justice but I don't particularly like the song they've chosen.

[Mr Jazzman]

Originally Posted by soundstory

I can't believe some of the comments here.

perhaps people should actually read what it's for first.....

There's plenty of horrible comments about the X Factor single.

Taken from another thread 'Both charity singles. The profits from one go to children with terminal illness, the profits from the other go to lawyers. Tough choice.'

[GARETH197901]

Originally Posted by Mr Jazzman

There's plenty of horrible comments about the X Factor single.

Taken from another thread 'Both charity singles. The profits from one go to children with terminal illness, the profits from the other go to lawyers. Tough choice.'

Easy Choice,buy both

[misslibertine]

Originally Posted by GARETH197901

Easy Choice,buy both

Or buy neither, and donate directly to the charities instead.

[GARETH197901]

Originally Posted by misslibertine

Or buy neither, and donate directly to the charities instead.

you could,but id rather buy the CD as gifts,and that's what many people will do,as it makes a easy christmas gift and helps the cause

[Smitharz]

I love the cover of The Justice Collective single.

[MeicY]

The song itself is generally considered a classic. Certainly one of the best harmonica lines.

As for the bullcrap about the profits going to lawyers, without the lawyers, the injustice of Hillsborough will never be overturned. If you were the victim of an injustice, you'd need a good lawyer or your life would be effectively taken away. The families of Hillsborough have had a large part of their lives taken away physically as well as officially and legally. They need money to fight against those who would deny them the chance to repudiate that.

Each to their own mind. Personally I think the care of terminally ill children (like care of veteran soldiers etc.) should be the responsibility of the state and shouldn't need any external charity funding. THAT'S another injustice that only lawyers could help remedy.

[Clancey83]

I love the song but not this version. It's just a standard charity single with a mix of voices that don't blend well. I'm all for supporting charity but that doesn't mean I'm going to clog my ipod with terrible music to do so.

[Sam Solitude]

I won't be buying/downloading any songs as I am skint !

[lady*tara]

Originally Posted by Mr Jazzman

There's plenty of horrible comments about the X Factor single.

Taken from another thread 'Both charity singles. The profits from one go to children with terminal illness, the profits from the other go to lawyers. Tough choice.'

For justice of dead people and children were also killed i cant believe how nasty you are against liverpool.

[shackfan]

Originally Posted by misslibertine

I would imagine most people know what its for. You don't have to love the song just because its for charity.

I fully support the Hillsborough fight for justice but I don't particularly like the song they've chosen.

I'm the other way round. Love the song, bored of the cause, but good luck to them.

[SamMcK]

Originally Posted by Kanzi

It's a pretty crap cover let's be honest. When are they finally going to put McCartney to bed?

I'll donate directly.

Maybe he would rather spend some of his final years doing what he loves instead of sitting in a chair at home in front of the TV because some people are ageist?