Originally Posted by seventhwave:
“This is the one she's dubbed "Gracie the nervous collie." (In addition to the late "Lizzie the nervous racehorse" and several other pets she calls "nervous.") Now, I understand that she takes in a lot of rescue animals, some of which come with psychological problems ... but it does strike me that something must be a bit wrong if so many of your pets are constantly "nervous"?”
Ok, I know I've only got cats, but I've rehomed 5 over the last 6 years, and cats come with issues too - and, just as with dogs, you have to take the time to understand your animal(s) and their (various) needs and adapt your ownership accordingly.
Both dogs and cats respond very well to 'clicker training' - I have, only this week and in only 4 days, trained one of my rehomed cats (who came to us as a terrible furniture-scratcher) to scratch his sisal mats and scratching posts instead of the sofas and chairs. Four days. A cat.
Ok, not as impressive as a dog, which would be able to be retrained over a much larger range of behaviours over a more sustanined time, but the principle is the same. How did I do it? By researching clicker training for cats (seeing as you can't take them to classes like you can dogs!) and even Liz will have dog training classes somewhere close to her rural idyll! Yes, it's bl**dy hard work when you're constantly and consistently reinforcing the behaviour you want (and you get through a lot of cat/dog treats - I keep finding them in pockets!) but it really works.
There's no excuse, Liz.
(Mind you, the other cats - the ones who don't have scratching issues - have quickly cottoned on to what's going on too, and there're all scratching the sisal mats madly too to join in with the treats!.

)
But, I forgot, it's always someone else's fault that Liz's dogs are untrained, isn't it - not hers. I mean, how are we to expect her to have the time to embark on something as fundamental as basic behaviour training for her assorted dogs, let alone stick to it consistently until that behaviour changes? Silly us. And poor Gracie for being left without the guidance she desperately needs (not to mention all the other animals - and especially the poor mauled cat from a few months back.

)
I agree with the person upthread who said it's not enough to just adopt/rehome an animal and feed them twice a day. They need the rest of it too - the consistent approach to what is acceptable behaviour to humans and other animals (if they live in a multi-pet household). Anything else is just not fair on the animal.