The Best New Series Story

doctorwhofancal · 11-02-2013, 13:08

These are the rules for the game

Series by series I will post the list of episodes from that series. The first 4 people to post a mark out of 10 will be the total, the top two from each series will go to the final when the lines will open for the top New Series Episode.

Series One:

Rose
End Of The World
The Unquiet Dead
Aliens Of London
World War Three
Dalek
The Long Game
Fathers Day
The Empty Child
The Doctor Dances
Boom Town
Bad Wolf
Parting Of The Ways

doctorwhofancal · 11-02-2013, 13:11

Rose- 7/10
End Of The World- 8/10
The Unquiet Dead- 5/10
Aliens Of London- 8/10
World War Three- 7/10
Dalek- 7/10
The Long Game- 6/10
Fathers Day- 5/10
The Empty Child- 8/10
The Doctor Dances- 7/10
Boom Town- 8/10
Bad Wolf- 9/10
Parting Of The Ways- 8/10

JohnnyForget · 11-02-2013, 14:08

Rose- 7/10
End Of The World- 6/10
The Unquiet Dead- 4/10
Aliens Of London- 2/10
World War Three- 2/10
Dalek- 8/10
The Long Game- 5/10
Fathers Day- 6/10
The Empty Child- 10/10
The Doctor Dances- 10/10
Boom Town- 6/10
Bad Wolf- 9/10
Parting Of The Ways- 9/10

ShootyDogThing · 11-02-2013, 14:27

Rose- 7/10
End Of The World- 6/10
The Unquiet Dead- 7/10
Aliens Of London- 6/10
World War Three- 6/10
Dalek- 9/10
The Long Game- 6/10
Fathers Day- 7/10
The Empty Child- 9/10
The Doctor Dances- 8/10
Boom Town- 6/10
Bad Wolf- 9/10
Parting Of The Ways- 10/10

Abomination · 11-02-2013, 14:42

Rose- 7/10
End Of The World- 7/10
The Unquiet Dead- 9/10
Aliens Of London- 7/10
World War Three- 7/10
Dalek- 9/10
The Long Game- 6/10
Fathers Day- 8/10
The Empty Child- 9/10
The Doctor Dances- 8/10
Boom Town- 7/10
Bad Wolf- 8/10
Parting Of The Ways- 9/10

CAMERA OBSCURA · 11-02-2013, 15:23

Rose 7/10
End Of The World 8/10
The Unquiet Dead 9/10
Aliens Of London 8/10
World War Three 7/10
Dalek 10/10
The Long Game 7/10
Fathers Day 10/10
The Empty Child 10/10
The Doctor Dances 10/10
Boom Town 8/10
Bad Wolf 10/10
Parting Of The Ways 10/10

sovietusername · 11-02-2013, 15:47

Rose 10/10
End of the world 5/10
The Unquiet Dead 6/10
Aliens of London/World War 3 5/10
Dalek 7/10
The Long Game 8/10
Fathers Day 9/10
The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances 8/10
Boom Town 4/10
Bad Wolf 6/10
Parting of the Ways 10/10

doctorwhofancal · 11-02-2013, 20:24

Rose- 7+7+7+7= 28
End Of The World- 8+6+6+7= 27
The Unquiet Dead- 5+4+7+9= 25
Aliens Of London- 8+2+6+7= 23
World War Three- 7+2+6+7= 22
Dalek- 7+8+9+9= 33
The Long Game- 6+5+6+6= 23
Fathers Day- 5+6+7+8= 26
The Empty Child- 8+10+9+9= 36
The Doctor Dances- 7+10+8+8= 33
Boom Town- 8+6+6+7= 27
Bad Wolf- 9+9+9+8= 35
Parting Of The Ways- 8+9+10+9= 36

Which means our finalists are:
The Empty Child
The Parting Of The Ways

Next up Series 2

Note: There will be an extra one for specials

doctorwhofancal · 11-02-2013, 20:28

New Earth- 8/10
Tooth & Claw- 7/10
School Reunion- 8/10
Girl In The Fireplace- 6/10
Rise Of The Cybermen- 9/10
The Age Of Steel- 8/10
The Idiots Lantern- 5/10
The Impossible Planet- 8/10
The Satan Pit- 7/10
Love and Monsters- 7/10
Fear Her- 4/10
Army Of Ghosts- 10/10
Doomsday- 10/10

Abomination · 11-02-2013, 20:33

New Earth- 7/10
Tooth & Claw- 8/10
School Reunion- 8/10
Girl In The Fireplace- 7/10
Rise Of The Cybermen- 7/10
The Age Of Steel- 7/10
The Idiots Lantern- 7/10
The Impossible Planet- 8/10
The Satan Pit- 8/10
Love and Monsters- 6/10
Fear Her- 5/10
Army Of Ghosts- 8/10
Doomsday- 8/10

JohnnyForget · 11-02-2013, 20:37

New Earth- 2/10
Tooth & Claw- 4/10
School Reunion- 7/10
Girl In The Fireplace- 9/10
Rise Of The Cybermen- 6/10
The Age Of Steel- 6/10
The Idiots Lantern- 2/10
The Impossible Planet- 8/10
The Satan Pit- 8/10
Love and Monsters- 5/10
Fear Her- 1/10
Army Of Ghosts- 7/10
Doomsday- 4/10

tomwozhere · 11-02-2013, 20:49

New earth - 5/10
Tooth and claw - 7/10
School reunion - 7/10
The girl in the fireplace - 10/10
Rise of the cybermen - 6/10
The age of steel - 6/10
The idiots lantern - 6/10
The impossible planet - 9/10
The satan pit - 9/10
Love and monsters - 4/10
Fear her - 5/10
Army of ghosts - 6/10
Doomsday - 7/10

supernovadragon · 11-02-2013, 21:06

New earth - 4/10
Tooth and claw - 7/10
School reunion - 9/10
The girl in the fireplace - 8/10
Rise of the cybermen - 7/10
The age of steel - 6/10
The idiots lantern - 4/10
The impossible planet - 8/10
The satan pit - 9/10
Love and monsters - 5/10
Fear her - 3/10
Army of ghosts - 7/10
Doomsday - 8/10

doctorwhofancal · 11-02-2013, 21:12

New Earth- 8+7+2+5= 22
Tooth & Claw- 7+8+4+7= 26
School Reunion- 8+8+7+7= 30
Girl In The Fireplace- 6+7+9+10= 32
Rise Of The Cybermen- 9+7+6+6= 28
The Age Of Steel- 8+7+6+6= 27
The Idiots Lantern- 5+7+2+6= 20
The Impossible Planet- 8+8+8+9= 33
The Satan Pit- 7+8+8+9= 32
Love and Monsters- 7+6+5+4= 22
Fear Her- 4+5+1+5= 15
Army Of Ghosts- 10+8+7+6= 31
Doomsday- 10+8+4+7= 29

Which means
The Impossible Planet is definaltey through however we have a tie between The Girl In The Fireplace and The Satan Pit. The first person to post who they want to be a finalist is a finalist!

Abomination · 11-02-2013, 21:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by doctorwhofancal

New Earth- 8+7+2+5= 22
Tooth & Claw- 7+8+4+7= 26
School Reunion- 8+8+7+7= 30
Girl In The Fireplace- 6+7+9+10= 32
Rise Of The Cybermen- 9+7+6+6= 28
The Age Of Steel- 8+7+6+6= 27
The Idiots Lantern- 5+7+2+6= 20
The Impossible Planet- 8+8+8+9= 33
The Satan Pit- 7+8+8+9= 32
Love and Monsters- 7+6+5+4= 22
Fear Her- 4+5+1+5= 15
Army Of Ghosts- 10+8+7+6= 31
Doomsday- 10+8+4+7= 29

Which means
The Impossible Planet is definaltey through however we have a tie between The Girl In The Fireplace and The Satan Pit. The first person to post who they want to be a finalist is a finalist!

The Satan Pit - it played with ideas the show rarely does, and asked some very adult, intelligent questions about religion. It was nice getting some Ten time and some Rose time, independent of each other. The production values were also brilliant.

TGitF looked the part, and was an interesting concept, but there was still something missing.

tomwozhere · 11-02-2013, 21:19

Couldn't we class them as one story and have The Girl In The Fireplace as well?

Abomination · 11-02-2013, 21:20

Quote:

Originally Posted by tomwozhere

Couldn't we class them as one story and have The Girl In The Fireplace as well?

This would work much nicer than a one-person vote out, which is purely down to luck

tomwozhere · 11-02-2013, 21:39

I would say that they are the same story (which this is about), just split in two episodes but obviously many of the two parters have one episode that's better than the other.

doctorwhofancal · 12-02-2013, 06:46

Quote:

Originally Posted by tomwozhere

I would say that they are the same story (which this is about), just split in two episodes but obviously many of the two parters have one episode that's better than the other.

Okay

This means our finalists are

The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances
Bad Wolf/ Parting Of The Ways
Girl In The Fireplace
The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit

Next up is Series 3

doctorwhofancal · 12-02-2013, 06:49

Smith and Jones- 8/10
The Shakespeare Code- 7/10
Gridlock- 9/10
Daleks Of Manhatten/Evolution Of The Daleks- 6/10
The Lazarus Experiment- 4/10
42- 4/10
Human Nature/Family Of Blood- 9/10
Blink- 8/10
Utopia/Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Time Lords- 5/10

JohnnyForget · 12-02-2013, 11:33

Smith and Jones- 5/10
The Shakespeare Code- 6/10
Gridlock- 4/10
Daleks Of Manhatten/Evolution Of The Daleks- 2/10
The Lazarus Experiment- 3/10
42- 6/10
Human Nature/Family Of Blood- 9/10
Blink- 10/10
Utopia/Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Time Lords- 6/10

Rowls · 12-02-2013, 11:37

Smith and Jones- 6/10
The Shakespeare Code- 7/10
Gridlock- 4/10
Daleks Of Manhatten/Evolution Of The Daleks- 4/10
The Lazarus Experiment- 3/10
42- 3/10
Human Nature/Family Of Blood- 8/10
Blink- 9/10
Utopia/Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Time Lords- 7/10

king yrcanos · 12-02-2013, 15:49

Smith and Jones-7/10
The Shakespeare Code-8/10
Gridlock-9/10
Daleks In Manhattan/Evoulotion of The Daleks-6/10
The Lazurus Experiment-6/10
42-7/10
Human Nature/Family of Blood-9/10
Blink-9/10
Utopia/Sound Of The Drums/Last of The Time Lords-6/10

doctorwhofancal · 12-02-2013, 16:23

Smith and Jones- 8+5+6+7= 26
The Shakespeare Code- 7+6+7+8= 28
Gridlock- 9+4+4+9= 26
Daleks Of Manhattan/Evolution Of The Daleks- 6+2+4+6= 18
The Lazarus Experiment: 4+3+3+6= 16
42- 4+6+3+7= 20
Human Nature/Family Of Blood- 9+9+8+9= 35
Blink- 8+10+9+9= 36
Utopia/Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Lords- 5+6+7+6= 24

Which means our finalists are
Human Nature/Family Of Blood
Blink

Next up is series 4

Abomination · 12-02-2013, 16:52

Partners in Crime - 7/10
The Fires of Pompeii - 7/10
Planet of the Ood - 9/10
The Sontaran Stratagem / The Poison Sky - 7/10
The Doctor's Daughter - 5/10
The Unicorn and the Wasp - 8/10
Silence in the Library / Forest of the Dead - 8/10
Midnight - 9/10
Turn Left - 8/10
The Stolen Earth / Journeys End - 8/10

11-02-2013, 13:08	#1
doctorwhofancal Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2012 Services: DS Strictly Dancefloor-Series 5+winter99 Big Brother winner! Host of DS IAC Posts: 6,017	The Best New Series Story These are the rules for the game Series by series I will post the list of episodes from that series. The first 4 people to post a mark out of 10 will be the total, the top two from each series will go to the final when the lines will open for the top New Series Episode. Series One: Rose End Of The World The Unquiet Dead Aliens Of London World War Three Dalek The Long Game Fathers Day The Empty Child The Doctor Dances Boom Town Bad Wolf Parting Of The Ways

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search

POPULAR SEARCHES ON DS

On Digital Spy

The Best New Series Story

Digital Spy

Network

Help

Search Digital Spy

11-02-2013, 13:11	#2
doctorwhofancal Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2012 Services: DS Strictly Dancefloor-Series 5+winter99 Big Brother winner! Host of DS IAC Posts: 6,017	Rose- 7/10 End Of The World- 8/10 The Unquiet Dead- 5/10 Aliens Of London- 8/10 World War Three- 7/10 Dalek- 7/10 The Long Game- 6/10 Fathers Day- 5/10 The Empty Child- 8/10 The Doctor Dances- 7/10 Boom Town- 8/10 Bad Wolf- 9/10 Parting Of The Ways- 8/10

11-02-2013, 14:08	#3
JohnnyForget Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 9,918	Rose- 7/10 End Of The World- 6/10 The Unquiet Dead- 4/10 Aliens Of London- 2/10 World War Three- 2/10 Dalek- 8/10 The Long Game- 5/10 Fathers Day- 6/10 The Empty Child- 10/10 The Doctor Dances- 10/10 Boom Town- 6/10 Bad Wolf- 9/10 Parting Of The Ways- 9/10

11-02-2013, 14:27	#4
ShootyDogThing Forum Member Join Date: Jun 2011 Posts: 717	Rose- 7/10 End Of The World- 6/10 The Unquiet Dead- 7/10 Aliens Of London- 6/10 World War Three- 6/10 Dalek- 9/10 The Long Game- 6/10 Fathers Day- 7/10 The Empty Child- 9/10 The Doctor Dances- 8/10 Boom Town- 6/10 Bad Wolf- 9/10 Parting Of The Ways- 10/10

11-02-2013, 14:42	#5
Abomination Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 2,279	Rose- 7/10 End Of The World- 7/10 The Unquiet Dead- 9/10 Aliens Of London- 7/10 World War Three- 7/10 Dalek- 9/10 The Long Game- 6/10 Fathers Day- 8/10 The Empty Child- 9/10 The Doctor Dances- 8/10 Boom Town- 7/10 Bad Wolf- 8/10 Parting Of The Ways- 9/10

11-02-2013, 15:23	#6
CAMERA OBSCURA Forum Member Join Date: Jan 2007 Posts: 4,379	Rose 7/10 End Of The World 8/10 The Unquiet Dead 9/10 Aliens Of London 8/10 World War Three 7/10 Dalek 10/10 The Long Game 7/10 Fathers Day 10/10 The Empty Child 10/10 The Doctor Dances 10/10 Boom Town 8/10 Bad Wolf 10/10 Parting Of The Ways 10/10

11-02-2013, 15:47	#7
sovietusername Inactive Member Join Date: Mar 2012 Services: facebook, youtube, skype Posts: 1,149	Rose 10/10 End of the world 5/10 The Unquiet Dead 6/10 Aliens of London/World War 3 5/10 Dalek 7/10 The Long Game 8/10 Fathers Day 9/10 The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances 8/10 Boom Town 4/10 Bad Wolf 6/10 Parting of the Ways 10/10

11-02-2013, 20:24	#8
doctorwhofancal Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2012 Services: DS Strictly Dancefloor-Series 5+winter99 Big Brother winner! Host of DS IAC Posts: 6,017	Rose- 7+7+7+7= 28 End Of The World- 8+6+6+7= 27 The Unquiet Dead- 5+4+7+9= 25 Aliens Of London- 8+2+6+7= 23 World War Three- 7+2+6+7= 22 Dalek- 7+8+9+9= 33 The Long Game- 6+5+6+6= 23 Fathers Day- 5+6+7+8= 26 The Empty Child- 8+10+9+9= 36 The Doctor Dances- 7+10+8+8= 33 Boom Town- 8+6+6+7= 27 Bad Wolf- 9+9+9+8= 35 Parting Of The Ways- 8+9+10+9= 36 Which means our finalists are: The Empty Child The Parting Of The Ways Next up Series 2 Note: There will be an extra one for specials

11-02-2013, 20:28	#9
doctorwhofancal Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2012 Services: DS Strictly Dancefloor-Series 5+winter99 Big Brother winner! Host of DS IAC Posts: 6,017	New Earth- 8/10 Tooth & Claw- 7/10 School Reunion- 8/10 Girl In The Fireplace- 6/10 Rise Of The Cybermen- 9/10 The Age Of Steel- 8/10 The Idiots Lantern- 5/10 The Impossible Planet- 8/10 The Satan Pit- 7/10 Love and Monsters- 7/10 Fear Her- 4/10 Army Of Ghosts- 10/10 Doomsday- 10/10

11-02-2013, 20:33	#10
Abomination Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 2,279	New Earth- 7/10 Tooth & Claw- 8/10 School Reunion- 8/10 Girl In The Fireplace- 7/10 Rise Of The Cybermen- 7/10 The Age Of Steel- 7/10 The Idiots Lantern- 7/10 The Impossible Planet- 8/10 The Satan Pit- 8/10 Love and Monsters- 6/10 Fear Her- 5/10 Army Of Ghosts- 8/10 Doomsday- 8/10

11-02-2013, 20:37	#11
JohnnyForget Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 9,918	New Earth- 2/10 Tooth & Claw- 4/10 School Reunion- 7/10 Girl In The Fireplace- 9/10 Rise Of The Cybermen- 6/10 The Age Of Steel- 6/10 The Idiots Lantern- 2/10 The Impossible Planet- 8/10 The Satan Pit- 8/10 Love and Monsters- 5/10 Fear Her- 1/10 Army Of Ghosts- 7/10 Doomsday- 4/10

11-02-2013, 20:49	#12
tomwozhere Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2011 Posts: 820	New earth - 5/10 Tooth and claw - 7/10 School reunion - 7/10 The girl in the fireplace - 10/10 Rise of the cybermen - 6/10 The age of steel - 6/10 The idiots lantern - 6/10 The impossible planet - 9/10 The satan pit - 9/10 Love and monsters - 4/10 Fear her - 5/10 Army of ghosts - 6/10 Doomsday - 7/10

11-02-2013, 21:06	#13
supernovadragon Forum Member Join Date: Feb 2011 Posts: 2,259	New earth - 4/10 Tooth and claw - 7/10 School reunion - 9/10 The girl in the fireplace - 8/10 Rise of the cybermen - 7/10 The age of steel - 6/10 The idiots lantern - 4/10 The impossible planet - 8/10 The satan pit - 9/10 Love and monsters - 5/10 Fear her - 3/10 Army of ghosts - 7/10 Doomsday - 8/10

11-02-2013, 21:12	#14
doctorwhofancal Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2012 Services: DS Strictly Dancefloor-Series 5+winter99 Big Brother winner! Host of DS IAC Posts: 6,017	New Earth- 8+7+2+5= 22 Tooth & Claw- 7+8+4+7= 26 School Reunion- 8+8+7+7= 30 Girl In The Fireplace- 6+7+9+10= 32 Rise Of The Cybermen- 9+7+6+6= 28 The Age Of Steel- 8+7+6+6= 27 The Idiots Lantern- 5+7+2+6= 20 The Impossible Planet- 8+8+8+9= 33 The Satan Pit- 7+8+8+9= 32 Love and Monsters- 7+6+5+4= 22 Fear Her- 4+5+1+5= 15 Army Of Ghosts- 10+8+7+6= 31 Doomsday- 10+8+4+7= 29 Which means The Impossible Planet is definaltey through however we have a tie between The Girl In The Fireplace and The Satan Pit. The first person to post who they want to be a finalist is a finalist!

11-02-2013, 21:19	#16
tomwozhere Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2011 Posts: 820	Couldn't we class them as one story and have The Girl In The Fireplace as well?

11-02-2013, 21:39	#18
tomwozhere Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2011 Posts: 820	I would say that they are the same story (which this is about), just split in two episodes but obviously many of the two parters have one episode that's better than the other.

12-02-2013, 06:49	#20
doctorwhofancal Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2012 Services: DS Strictly Dancefloor-Series 5+winter99 Big Brother winner! Host of DS IAC Posts: 6,017	Smith and Jones- 8/10 The Shakespeare Code- 7/10 Gridlock- 9/10 Daleks Of Manhatten/Evolution Of The Daleks- 6/10 The Lazarus Experiment- 4/10 42- 4/10 Human Nature/Family Of Blood- 9/10 Blink- 8/10 Utopia/Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Time Lords- 5/10

12-02-2013, 11:33	#21
JohnnyForget Forum Member Join Date: Aug 2010 Posts: 9,918	Smith and Jones- 5/10 The Shakespeare Code- 6/10 Gridlock- 4/10 Daleks Of Manhatten/Evolution Of The Daleks- 2/10 The Lazarus Experiment- 3/10 42- 6/10 Human Nature/Family Of Blood- 9/10 Blink- 10/10 Utopia/Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Time Lords- 6/10

12-02-2013, 11:37	#22
Rowls Forum Member Join Date: Jul 2010 Posts: 131	Smith and Jones- 6/10 The Shakespeare Code- 7/10 Gridlock- 4/10 Daleks Of Manhatten/Evolution Of The Daleks- 4/10 The Lazarus Experiment- 3/10 42- 3/10 Human Nature/Family Of Blood- 8/10 Blink- 9/10 Utopia/Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Time Lords- 7/10

12-02-2013, 15:49	#23
king yrcanos Forum Member Join Date: Jun 2012 Location: Zeta Minor Posts: 1,328	Smith and Jones-7/10 The Shakespeare Code-8/10 Gridlock-9/10 Daleks In Manhattan/Evoulotion of The Daleks-6/10 The Lazurus Experiment-6/10 42-7/10 Human Nature/Family of Blood-9/10 Blink-9/10 Utopia/Sound Of The Drums/Last of The Time Lords-6/10

12-02-2013, 16:23	#24
doctorwhofancal Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2012 Services: DS Strictly Dancefloor-Series 5+winter99 Big Brother winner! Host of DS IAC Posts: 6,017	Smith and Jones- 8+5+6+7= 26 The Shakespeare Code- 7+6+7+8= 28 Gridlock- 9+4+4+9= 26 Daleks Of Manhattan/Evolution Of The Daleks- 6+2+4+6= 18 The Lazarus Experiment: 4+3+3+6= 16 42- 4+6+3+7= 20 Human Nature/Family Of Blood- 9+9+8+9= 35 Blink- 8+10+9+9= 36 Utopia/Sound Of Drums/Last Of The Lords- 5+6+7+6= 24 Which means our finalists are Human Nature/Family Of Blood Blink Next up is series 4

POPULAR SEARCHES ON DS

My DS Account

On Digital Spy

The Best New Series Story

Digital Spy

Network

Help

Search Digital Spy

12-02-2013, 16:52	#25
Abomination Forum Member Join Date: Apr 2010 Posts: 2,279	Partners in Crime - 7/10 The Fires of Pompeii - 7/10 Planet of the Ood - 9/10 The Sontaran Stratagem / The Poison Sky - 7/10 The Doctor's Daughter - 5/10 The Unicorn and the Wasp - 8/10 Silence in the Library / Forest of the Dead - 8/10 Midnight - 9/10 Turn Left - 8/10 The Stolen Earth / Journeys End - 8/10