Originally Posted by whedon247:
“there is no doubting that TNA is terrible right now though.
and thats coming from someone who defended TNA for over a decade now.”
Originally Posted by ags_rule:
“Agreed, TNA is at a real downpoint right now. I think they're suffering partly because of their own ineptitude, but also because WWE have upped their game recently. Most people don't have the time to commit to watching 5 hours (or more) of wrestling a week. So if it's a choice between RAW and Impact, the decision - at the minute - is an easy one.
WWE has struck gold with Bryan. The Shield and the Wyatts are both hot properties. There's a lot of emerging talent such as Cesaro and the folks coming up from NXT. And there's enough nostalgic throwbacks to keep more casual fans (such as myself) invested.
What does TNA have? A half-hearted power struggle between MVP and Dixie Carter, which is laughable in itself. A guy who is most famous for doing ridiculous things and appearing on Animal Planet as their heavyweight champ, after defeating Magnus whose reign can only be termed a disaster. They've lost Sting, Hogan, Styles, Daniels, Kazarian and others. Aries is in the doghouse and is unlikely to last in the company, and certainly unlikely to get another monster push. Storm, Roode and Bully Ray are as competent as ever but wasted in their current roles. Angle's body is broken and it is clear he is counting down the days to a retirement match at Wrestlemania. Willow was an intriguing idea for Hardy but has been terribly executed. Spud, EC3 and the rest of the 'new blood' are all OK, but there's nobody there you can build a company around. And that is the problem. They have jettisoned nearly all of their most marketable performers, all at the same time as they rebranded their most marketable performer in Jeff Hardy.
The company is in a terminal decline and it is difficult to see if it can be halted. It will require time and another major rebranding, as well as a focused push of new talent. But are the current creative team up to the job? Is Dixie Carter up to the job? Is the talent there? By and large, the answer has to be no.
And before anybody accuses me of being a WWE fanboy, please look at my post history in the TNA and WWE threads. I have defended TNA to the hilt on inumerable occasions, but they are in a terrible state right now and largely indefensible.”
Well, you guys are entitled to your own personal view of the product, but I disagree with the idea that "there is no doubting" the product is bad or that liking it is "indefensible". Everybody is entitled to their own opinion.
Personally, I've enjoyed Impact a lot more since Hogan left. Storylines make a lot more sense, matches and main events are (finally!) advertised a week in advance, and there's a greater variety of wrestling styles and angles. For example, you've got some pure X-div with Tigre and Sanada, some hardcore with Gunner / Storm, some soap opera with Anderson / Shaw, and plenty of (actually quite good) comedy with Spud / EC3 / Willow and Bromans. The main event scene has definitely suffered from Magnus / Joe failing to deliver, but is likely to improve with a worker like EY at its centre. The show has rarely been better balanced.
The thing they've lost is star power. Personally I don't care about that, and if it was necessary to cut that adrift to keep the company afloat then so be it.