Originally Posted by
Stuart25:
“I'd like each of you now to explain why you think you should be in the final over the other candidates (you can use weaknesses of the others to display your strengths).
”
I think that I should be in the final because I have worked incredibly hard on the tasks, I've come up with good ideas in all of them (with the possible exception of the TV task, but even on that one I tried my hardest even though it didn't work out) and I'm very fair and honest. I know I don't have so much business experience, but I think on the whole I have proved I'm not just a one-trick pony and I really have enough basic knowledge of business to be able to do well. I was Project Manager on a task that I would have described as really not being my bag, but I delegated the tasks well and I tried hard to keep costs down. I know we lost that task because of high costs, but you made it clear that that wasn't to do with me, and you said that I myself had done a good job. I have weaknesses and my business plan has weaknesses, including a huge one where the figures should be - but I am honest enough to accept that and work with it. And there are weaknesses in all three business plans, so I don't think mine should be rejected for that.
In terms of who should go, both Nick and Eliza are fantastic and it would be a shame to lose either of them - but on the whole, I think Nick has generally proved to be more impressive and has a more innovative business idea, so by default I would fire Eliza. It's very close though.