I have a question for everyone in here, and it's just purely out of curiosity...
I would consider myself a casual Rock & Metal fan, and I do have a crazy diverse music taste - anyway, when I was about 12/13, Evanescence brought out Bring Me To Life - and it was literally Amy's voice that drew me into the song, prior to that (and being a kid) I was just mainly into whatever my parents were listening to, or whatever was in the chart etc. I've always credited that song (and the band) for wanting me to expand my taste and explore the more 'rockier' spectrum of music.
Anyway, I've always noticed in a lot of communities, particularly the Metal community - they're very quick to shoot down any discussion about Evanescence because they're not seen as "proper rock".
The question is, however, would people in here consider them as a Hard Rock band ? I mean I know there
are pop elements to their music (particularly the first two albums), but their latest is probably their most mature and definitely the heaviest - from the purely band and vocals standpoint. I mean I know a lot of fans do
like to consider them metal, but when you're comparing them to 'similar' acts (Eg. a female fronted band) you can see the likes of Nightwish, Within Temptation, Haelstorm, etc are all much more "metal" than Ev.
For example, everyone knows Bring Me To Life, but then comparing it to their music 8 years on:
Made of Stone:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9ZWginVQHM
Never Go Back:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VuLt8Tmp2c8
I'm just curious as this forum is a lot more diverse than just one specifically for metal music.
(FYI, I'm not trying to argue that they are or aren't, I'm just curious about people's opinions on them, I just take them as they are because I enjoy the music whether they're classed as metal, hard rock or pop rock lol)